u/D0ntAtMeBr0

Monstrous ability payment + Dying

If [[Hythonia the Cruel]] has it's Monstrous ability activated, and in response, I kill it, will it still wipe the board when it's ability goes to resolve, despite it being dead and thus not being able to become monstrous?

reddit.com
u/D0ntAtMeBr0 — 2 days ago

Phasing out in response to chaos warp

I understand that [[Chaos Warp]] will let me reveal and potentially play the top card of my library, however in response I phase out my commander. I understand there is no longer a target for the spell, but will I get to still complete chaos warp or does it fully fizzle and prevent me from getting anything from the top of my library?

reddit.com
u/D0ntAtMeBr0 — 2 days ago

Will Urabrask exile and transform at the beginning of the turn it resolves it's 3rd chaper ability?

Just as title says will [[Urabrask]] transform from his saga The Great Work back into Urabrask at the beginning of his turn when he hits stage 3 on the saga side? Meaning all instants he sees would allow him to ping everyone and deal damage?

reddit.com
u/D0ntAtMeBr0 — 4 days ago

Memnarch vs protection from colors?

If my opponent controls a [[Memnarch]] and targets my commander with its ability to change target permanent into an artifact and I control a [[Mother of Runes]], would tapping her to give my commander protection from blue prevent the memnarch ability from targeting and resolving on my commander?

reddit.com
u/D0ntAtMeBr0 — 4 days ago

There's an interaction I wanted to check, if I use [[Final Showdown]] paying the first spree cost to make all creatures lose all abilities till end of turn in response to something like a [[Balan, Wandering Knight]] using it's activated ability to attach all equipment. Would that ability still resolve as normal and attach all equipment to balan?

So stack would be from bottom to top - 1. Balan activated ability | 2. Final Showdown removing abilities from all creatures

reddit.com
u/D0ntAtMeBr0 — 16 days ago

So I was just wondering after reading the final ability of [[Talon Gates of Madara]] which reads [pay 4 generic]: Put this card from your hand onto the battlefield.
And when it enters, up to 1 target creature phases out.

Would this mean that if my opponent controls a [[Grand Abolisher]] this effect could still be activated and could even phase out the Grand Abolisher to allow spells to be cast and abilities to be activated from Creatures, Enchantments, and Artifacts again?

Also for the sake of targeting, I understand that Hexproof would prevent me from targeting a creature with Talon Gate's ETB trigger, but outside of "Protection from Everything", there's no form of protection that could prevent this phase effect right? Since the land doesn't have a colour identity, nor is it an instant or sorcery, nor is it an activated ability etc.

reddit.com
u/D0ntAtMeBr0 — 16 days ago

I had a game where I was helping a friend get into MTG over Tabletop Sim, he's playing an Izzet Otter deck that he netdecked, at one point he played [[Epic Experiment]] and one of the cards exiled [[Grab the Prize]] and another was [[See Double]]

We were a little unsure of this interaction since I dont typically play effects like this. We assumed that since Epic Experiment says "Cast without paying their mana costs", an additional cost such as discard would not be ignored and must still be paid. Is there any scenario when casting "for free" when you wouldn't need to pay an additional cost outside of X always being 0 if a spell is cast that way?

In addition, he also targeted Grab the Prize with See Double to copy it. I am aware that copying a spell onto the stack doesn't count as casting, so I assume you wouldn't have to pay the additional cost again.

We resolved this as he discarded 1 card and ended up drawing 4 cards, with a storm count of 3 after the Epic Experiment, first instance of Grab the Prize, and See Double resolved. Is this all correct or?

reddit.com
u/D0ntAtMeBr0 — 17 days ago