u/Dawud___

What do you think of Ethan Muse and his argumentation of "Padre Pio" stuff?

What do you think of Ethan Muse and his argumentation of "Padre Pio" stuff?

Not a Catholic, not even an Ex-Catholic, I'm actually a Muslim, I came across this guy Ethan Muse's Substack where he argues for Catholic "miracles", and one of them was regarding the alleged miracles associated with a man known as "Padre Pio"

Now, I'll be honest, I know very little about the man known as "Padre Pio" himself, it's not like with the whole "Miracle of Fatima" stuff where I actually already had a bit of knowledge regarding that stuff, and could easily see how flawed Ethan Muse's argumentation was for that, the way Ethan argues it's very much in a sort of trying to be slick with language sort of way from what I can remember from his argumentation for that

So, I thought I'd ask here, see what people think, this was his Substack post on the man known as "Padre Pio":

https://motivacredibilitatis.substack.com/p/st-pio-of-pietrelcina

u/Dawud___ — 2 days ago