u/DisastrousAdvance12

I’m renting from Enterprise at Orlando Sanford Airport (SFB) for a week in July.
I currently have two pay-at-pickup reservations:
You Click. We Pick.
Jeep Wrangler Unlimited or similar
The Wrangler reservation is only about $55 more for the entire week.
A couple years ago, I used You Click. We Pick. at the same airport and ended up with a Wrangler, but I know that was probably just luck and I could just as easily get a compact or midsize this time.
What would you do in this situation?
Would you keep both reservations until pickup and decide then, or choose one ahead of time?
If you’ve rented from Sanford recently, what did you end up getting with You Click. We Pick.?
Just looking for opinions and experiences before I decide. Thanks!