u/EnriquePorque

Hi there,

Considering the ogre can be evil about 1/3 of the time and that the ST has almost no leeway to towards rebalancing the game in this script, doesn't that unbalance the game towards evil in those games where they steal 1 good person from the enemy team ?

Can having at the end -1 good ghost vote / +1 evil ghost vote be the difference winning and losing ?

I can understand why the Butler doesn't get a lot of love, but TB is balanced with this 100% good team character in mind. Replacing it with a 66% good /33% evil character feels that it would unbalance those 33% games.

Ogre interactions are super fun, but I wonder if the character is really fit in a TB-like script.

What's your take on this ?

Hi,

I was discussing this topic with m'y gaming group, and it looks like we don't all share the same opinion about this.

Personally, I don't like breaking madness and voluntarily hiding it from the ST, as it could create certain metas about which evil player snitched on me, in case I get executed by the ST, or a bluff meta from evil.

What's your take on this ?

Hello,

Link to the script in question.

I consider myself a better than average storyteller, but I will run this script for the first time, and the question of balancing the starting composition of the characters kind of looks difficult. Does anybody play with this script, and has some tips and pointers to give me to pay attention to ?

Thank you !

Hello,

I'm looking to modify the script Uncertain Death, which is unbalanced in favor of good, in order to give back some of the power to the evil team. But I also want to keep the spirit of the script, which is to hunt down the poison to look for the demon and have a rather simple script to play for unexperienced players.

At the moment, I have these scripts I would like to test out, can you give me your opinion about it ? I was also considering the politician and the minstrel.

Thank you !

https://preview.redd.it/phzqj051hech1.png?width=2155&format=png&auto=webp&s=d3bd98545a4e25cd7d29f8ac637a9f57f2fc130a

https://preview.redd.it/5v1w7dh6iech1.png?width=2155&format=png&auto=webp&s=3d9fa64324926a784dbef71a76fbf514e3431554