I have a Emonda ALR5 (2025): wich add?: Scott Addict 40 (2026) (no gravel model) or Checkpoint ALR5 or Crux DSW
Hi everyone, I have a Trek Emonda ALR5 with a few upgrades: Shimano 105 Di2, DT Swiss ER1600 30 wheels with G5K rims, an Enve carbon seatpost, and Ergon 312R carbon handlebars. I love this bike.
I was thinking of buying a gravel bike or something that allows for wider tires. While searching in my city, I found the following options:
1-Scott Addict 40 (2026) (not the gravel model) - I always wanted this bike; before buying the ALR5, I wanted it but they didn’t have my size (XS)
2-Checkpoint ALR5
3-Crux DSW
I know the Addict 40 isn’t a gravel model, but it can handle tires up to 40mm without any issues. I feel like if I buy this one, it would overlap in use with my Emonda ALR5.
The Checkpoint ALR5 is the one that appeals to me the most because of its more relaxed geometry and the fact that I can fit tires up to 50mm on it.
With the Crux DSW, I’m concerned that it’s an aggressive model, and basically my gravel rides are 5–6 hours on gravel trails with rocky climbs.
I’m turning to your wisdom and knowledge.
What would you recommend I do? Assuming I can find my size for each bike. My idea is to have a bike that can handle light to moderate gravel, since I already have a Scott Scale 40 for rough terrain or hills.