u/Fantastic_Young_3032

as its past 2 weeks since class started, how is it going? honest reviews only pls..

bro i cant BELEIVE ITTTTT WE ARE GETTING THIS SERVEEEEEEDDDD, now is the time for all of us to hype tjjd for what it serves . LESGOGOOGOG!!!

Can we first talk about how GOOD today’s episode actually was, keeping aside the last few seconds?? 😭 Everyone is so busy discussing what might happen that nobody is talking about what we actually got today.

I understand why everyone is triggered. SA is an extremely sensitive topic and the concern about how they’ll handle it is completely valid. But how do we expect better episodes when we only pick apart what’s wrong and barely acknowledge when something is done well? Constructive criticism goes both ways.

And honestly, I’m willing to wait and see how they execute this before crashing out 😭. Sargun surely has enough brains to know SA isn’t something you introduce and then handle while smoking whatever they’ve been smoking for some of these tracks 💀.

There HAVE been inconsistencies — like Fateh hugging Heer and her showing basically no reaction, when realistically you’d expect some kind of trigger. But I also think they hadn’t fully figured out what they wanted her past to be at that point.

I’m not defending the makers. If they mess it up, criticize them. But maybe let them actually mess it up first 😭. The current writers are also behind Yeh Fitoor Tera, where a similar sensitive issue is a major part of the story and has been handled pretty well.

So relax, watch it unfold, and PLEASE give a good episode its flowers when we actually get one 😭

this is more directed towards X.. all they do is crashout and blame , we civil around here

and that speaks volumes.

honestly everything pointed towards me personally to her having fear of being murdered.. less molestation, if it was molestation honestly i felt like the signs wudve been more obvious and something more different with a little flashbacks.. i am not convinced it is molestation yet. the only scene which pointed towards a possibility of molestation for me was the scene in yesterdays episode where she came into washroom where cherry vaaris and fateh where there and she came in being scared they did sumth to cherry. that kind of put me off and directed towards molestation.. other than that nothing else.

also if they are handling SA case, first of all SA is not a plot device, and if they dont handle it as a plot device and rather use it to create awareness, itll be goood. Heer opening up about it, and nawab helping her through it out. My fear is they will show fateh helping her through it out.. for now im ok with fateh throwing in some quotes from pinterest and helping heer realise who SHE IS. But then after that let fateechar go away. + nawab has to help her before he finds the truth. or there wont be any impact of him helping her because he knows shes not guilty . it should come from within and not circumstantial.

because time to time jasmeet replies to my messages, i messaged her and sent her ss of the ongoing problems we are facing, and with suggestions and asking to make the team aware about the audience feedback. and usually jasmeet replies to the messages, but this time she only opened them , i was pretty sure she wud not be abled to reply to messages about the show as might be unproffesional , so i had sent it as pictures so i cud see if she had viewed it. and she did . my aim was just to make her aware and atleast she is aware about the issue and that the audience feedback is negative.

i had sent tweets saying the leads are going to be sidelined with the new gen entries, and all screenshots where people are reacting to the dressing, and the negative feedback ( ofc only the constructive criticism) , she has seen all of them as i can see she has opened all of them. its very clear in that the people dont like the sideling of the leads at all, or the styling. and ones who were excited for the leap before are'nt anymore

i am hoping that she takes all of this seriously, and raises this with the respective cast members and they execute this track well, and bring out good styling, and no sideling of the leads which everyone is afraid of.

ps: comments

same as title

would love to connect with classmates !! joining in this sep :)

see i know , the makers have bad past records, and they love ragebaiting us etc. but lets not get on top of our heads and stop enjoying the current eps too in fear of the future. you are not going to get these first hand experience of these good eps anymore after the day u watch it for the first time, so dont watch it in fear.

and my theory is that they released it just to test the waters. as clearly it was only released to a group of ppl but was leaked. so this is not finalised , so lets not all go over our heads now, and go into theories of razmeet being sidelined, bcs they are the usp of the show and if they do that the show ends there and then. when the show was absolute shit, me and many of us stayed back only for razmeet and they are well aware of it.

i 100% agree the styling is absolute shit, but if this is the way of testing waters, then i think they've tested the waters and its turned into a tsunami bcs everyone hates it so theyll prolly handle it . and wht we shud do is when promo comes out , go under sarguns and the promo post and tell about the styling. instead of crashing out, and posting bye bye heewab posts

like comon man, the whole cast says sumn interesting coming, sarguns romance ka vaada, leap is coming , etc. and now everyone is posting bye bye heewab and overinterprating jasmeet's caption.

the same thing happened yesterday, colors posted the confession clip and everyone went crazy saying.... nawab is going to get memory loss- behen there's no memory loss in the story itself.

and somany of the times we've been proved wrong. so lets just relax. in the end there won't be a difference between constant criticism , and constructive criticism. let's wait this one out. and relax, and enjoy the episodes rn.

nowadays, i feel the old heewab feels, and fd feels where everyone is gng crazy analysing and theorising and i lovveee this. the fd is one of the special parts of tjjd, nd i see the spark even more nw. seeing hw the weekly visitors kept dropping down weeks back, and is back up again , makes me feel so good!!. and seeing the theories i feel soosos excitedd for the upcoming track. ik it cud go bad and everything, but honestly im gonna tie all my hopes into this.

i am gng out of station on monday and will come back only by the monday after. so ill prolly miss the leap promo discussions and the ep itselffff but im rrealllyyy excited to come back and binge. after a long timee.

anti jinx spray, no nazar.

https://preview.redd.it/y3rykdhfobjh1.png?width=1200&format=png&auto=webp&s=9f705b53b147da0f86b3292498284311349d3410

so im a lil nosy, idk if anyone else noticed this when suraj was showing his laptop i paused nd saw that they have a doc w leap promo titled document so we will get a promo for it

THANK GOD bcs i thought they wud prolly give a promo after all the eps aired and compile them tg.. what if they were shooting for the leap promo yday, and the bts released was that..

but yes finally some new promo hopefullyyyy

literally, back to back perfect episodes with amazing execution, where i feel like waking up earlier to watch the eps, its literally amazing and literally NO NAZAR i am getting my heewab back. and i am lowkey so excited for the leap asw bcs that fresh start we deserve , im pretty positive this time. LESGOOOOOO appreciattteee ittttt

the recent episodes, from my pov from starting of august have been absolutely amazing, especially post seperation. i didnt think seperation would give us THIS MUCH.

honestly during seperation is when the writers and heewab shine, you can see how intense their feelings are, and the yearning and everything about it etc. initially i thought the seperation was destined to be similar like simran track which traumatised us, but thankfully the writers knew to not show anything like that between nimrat, and nawab. and the episode today was so good. SO GOOD. the aesthetics SO GOOD. the characters are peaking again, in todays ep they cudve shown nawab jumping into the room to save heer, but they showed heer and nawab like how they are : heer will save herself and progress

nawab will put himself into danger

and now when he gets to know heer is in danger he'll come to save her too, this is SO like them. i know people wanted the root cause of the seperation to hit nawab and them to talk about it, but i have a feeling that will happen too. just in time, when the climax happens? i am not sure where the story is headed, but the team is doing a wonderful job now , except for that rave kutta, this could potentially be one of my favs track after thailavathi, biwi hai meri, and post remarraige track.

may i say we are so back....?

also pls b praak ka come back nahi karo bhai

initially when i heard about seperation track i was very half hearted about it, bcs last time the seperation started, we had to send them death threats to end it ( not literally) , but , todays episode changed my perspective. heewab were'nt laughing and giggling running around but i still felt the episode was good, there was proper communication- which was nawab fighting for her. as he was acting like he had lost his voice box in raja dhabha for the past few episodes. and the episodes, reactions, THE yearning was so evident. i absolutely loved it, if they can write seperation like this, then continue bhai. i would 100% prefer this over the nonsense they showed post reunion eps ( apart from the few good eps in the start of post reunion) , today they genuinely showed scenes where we actually FEEL them, how they felt. not like the other episodes where we have to make assumptions about how either of them feel, or think. i felt something in this episode after so long. i wish they could do the same for the episodes when they were tg, except for the few eps they did. so lets just buckle in and hope they serve as they are doing right now.

i know "memory loss" is a very sensitive topic for our fd now keeping in mind the terrible execution of the makers, and their love for seperation and third angles, but hear me out. this is the version i wud make, imagining sonal is still the writer, amit sir is still the director, and the initial pre biwi hai meri spark still persists,( warning- this is not college centric and is away from college premises ):

Heer and Nawab is finally away from all the struggles they faced, they are on a drive to their honeymoon in goa, but on their way they discover their car's breaks have been tampered with. ( you can choose who the villian who tampered the breaks as the show has given us plenty of options to choose as the villian). due to the faulty breaks they get into a car accident, and both Heer and Nawab are lost. Nawab's family members find him, and declare heer as dead, as they couldnt find heer even after relentless search . then we see, Nawab yearning, sad. and compeletely broken, in his bewda look. but he beleives heer is out there somewhere.

while heer is seen to be in a village, and she has suffered memory loss due to a head injury. her body was discovered by the river bank, and rescued. heer is revived by a elderly sweet woman who takes up the responsibility of taking care of her, and the elderly woman has a son of heer's age who has a healthy crush on heer, their are other siblings too, and heer finally feels what a healthy family feels like.. However, heer has no idea of her name, who she is and where she comes from. she only remembers vivid flashbacks of someone calling her thailawathi. and everyone around her starts calling her that assuming that is her name. she occasionally receives blurry flashbacks of her time with nawab but she isnt abled to see who it is, or what exactly they mean . heer spends her time being a dance teacher, teaching the students and kids of the village, as she tries to fund for her security, education etc.

post 1 month leap, nawab is still depressed, and not abled to handle himself, his family helps him get out of his bewda-ness and motivates him to work in the brar industries as nawab does not go to cpu as all the memories there is tied to heer. because of a project initated in the village heer resides in , nawab has to go to the village to visit the site. he goes there to see heer, dancing, (FLASHBACK TO CPU HEER REHEARSAL BEFORE DANCE COMPEITION NAWAB RECORDING HEER) , and nawab is in disbeleif. heer sees nawab and faints after getting many flashbacks. the doctors reach heers house, and nawab waits for heer to wake up to tell her the truth , the doctors tell nawab not to give her this huge chunk of revelation at once, and that this could put her health to risk, and asks him to allow her to retrace her path by herself.

nawab agrees to it, and then the track shows nawab living in the villiage, disguised as a commoner, working day and night just to catch a glimpse of her, them being friends, and having nok jhoks, plenty of village events, nawab works like ram in Ramaiya Vastavaiya just to be around her, he gets jealous of the son who has a crush on her and who tries to be around her. and the track shows a reverse- thailawathi track, where heer doesnt know nawab is her husband and she falls in love with him again, leading to a pati hein mera.

if you want this to be CPU centric, alternatively, heer wud be rescued and she wud be undergoing memory loss with multiple flashbacks etc, she enters cpu as TA as she wants to fund her survival, etc and she has 0 idea what is dragging her there, and she sees nawab there and the same story goes on there.. where slowly heer uncovers her identity.

same as title plss :)

from 5:24- 5:30 , lol bhai script bts nahi diya toh reel decode karne me lagg gayi

as we know that the dadi is finding peices of bangle around the house etc, which clearly shows they want to reveal to dadi about heer's marraige. can that lead up to dadi after finding about heer's marraige ask her to see her husband, and now they have to bring in a fake husband , and theres a whole track for that going on, and nawab shows his junooniyat , jealousy side. that would be such a fun track, and a good parallel to the biwi hai meri track which they are clearly tryna recreate.

so makers saw how everyone was holding on to the secret dating trope SOMUCH , during the leap phase. but they cudnt deliver that ( prolly bcs they thought simmu didi track wud make us feel alot better bcs they know us so well <3333) so now they r gonna start running the secret dating track to satisfy the genz audience, and now to pull in the tv audience they are adding a saas bahu element to it too.

i hope they do justice to this track bcs its been HIGHLY anticipated for, i used to see a story daily of ppl holding on to their last bit of hope on to the secret dating trope, and after the trend today i hope they make some changes in the execution + writing team.

I am not saying we are so back yet, hamara go back hojayega .

i understand constructive criticism completely, and the whole " for the shows betterment " kind of thing, but now genuinenly its constant nitpicking. just ruining the essence of the show, and the episodes. seeing people complain for issues like - not writing heers character properly, or introducing simran track etc. is compeletely understood. and i stand with that, but nitpicking and doing crazy manifestations for memory loss track, WHILST BEING THE SAME PEOPLE WHO WERE CRYING TO BRING HEEWAB TG DURING THE SEPERATION, demanding for another one, KNOWING FULL WELL THE WRITERS ARE NOT THE OG WRITERS AND WILL NOT DO JUSTICE TO THE TRACK OR THE CHARACTERS. it will be new people in both heewabs lives, etc. u are not gonna get a phase like thailawathi again, and lets not try to recreate it.

post wedding, the makers did SO SO WELL. they actually showed such cute scenes, but people found some or other way to keep . complaining. mr sandhu, gareebi arc. etc. i understand the logic behind it, but when the noise about the negatives increase, its hard to see the positives. just like this during the 15 day challenge track the essence was ruined bcs everyone was behind the gareebi of the ph and standards. i understand it is a concern, but that was all being highlighted, now when i look back at it. thats all i remember. it was such a beautiful track.

we are genuinely blessed with tu juliet jatt di, i am not abled to start any serial to watch rn bcs this serial is one of its kind.the other serials have this dramatic element to it, this saas bahu kind. this paticular element im not being abled to pinpoint which tjjd never showed. and that makes it different and unique. and the fd which was once the most beautiful part of the show, has become one of the most exhausting part. having split fds, "x" people, " reddit" people, heer supporters nawab supporters, in the end of the day isnt the main aim to celebrate HEEWAB?

can you seriously just pause and think about it.

this fd is complaining now because the show is showing TOO MANY dances. ??????????

the cast is working so hard day and night, and all they have to do is nickpick and constant agitations. and concerns for PDA is understandable as they have lacked in that, but not letting cute, wholesome moments of them live because you want them to full on PDA, just shows sumn else. heewab is tg, and they are literally building their rs tg, but nah this is boring now, they want to seperate them and show " angst" thailavathi track dupe now.

with the writers we have right now, even if we get memory loss track, we will see the temu version of thailavathi track, and here you go another thing to nitpick and draw parallels about. if they draw parallels theyll go on about how this show doesnt know how to write they just recreate and draw parallels.

hope the fd gets some shit into their head soon, we are so blessed.

ive been wanting to ask this, and wud be really happy if EVERYONE in the sub jot down their opinions, be it people who left the show, people who currently love the show or anything. what is your opinion on the show? what do you like and dislike? what track wud u want to see the show bringing in. please dont downvote if someones opinion doesnt match yours.. comon in and vent/rant whatever! ( constructive criticism tho not going on an actors irl acting etc)