u/Fun-Ad-8760

Image 1 — 1938 D Buffalo
Image 2 — 1938 D Buffalo
Image 3 — 1938 D Buffalo
Image 4 — 1938 D Buffalo
Image 5 — 1938 D Buffalo
Image 6 — 1938 D Buffalo
Image 7 — 1938 D Buffalo
Image 8 — 1938 D Buffalo
▲ 4 r/coincollecting+1 crossposts

1938 D Buffalo

Got this NGC Slabbed MS 66. A couple questions.

  1. should I get it regraded? It’s an older case and I wonder if it would grade 67.

  2. I can’t tell if it’s the case, lighting or both, but it almost looks like a slight RPM.

Any thoughts?

Thank you in advance. Sorry if pics aren’t great.

u/Fun-Ad-8760 — 6 days ago

1939 Mercury Dime — Possible Struck-Through / Retained Die Break

Found this 1939 Mercury dime while going through a silver lot and noticed a really unusual raised area covering most of Liberty’s face/forehead.
At first I assumed environmental damage or corrosion, but after taking macro and side-angle photos, the metal flow and surface texture look more integrated into the strike than I expected. The area appears raised rather than sunken, and the rim/reeding still look normal.
A few people suggested:
struck-through retained debris

heavy grease strike / filled die

retained die break or late-stage die deterioration

I haven’t been able to find another documented 1939 Mercury dime with this exact appearance.
Not claiming anything definitive — just trying to determine whether this is:
a legitimate mint error
or

post-mint damage that happens to mimic one

Would appreciate opinions from error specialists or Mercury dime collectors.

u/Fun-Ad-8760 — 15 days ago

Wondering if I should get these graded or keep in cellophane as a set. Any marks I have seen are on cellophane. They stay in place when I move a coin.

u/Fun-Ad-8760 — 26 days ago