u/Fun_Air_2527

I will admit that the art is uneven at times. Women sometimes have Barbie hips, and some of the silhouettes look really jagged. But most of the time it creates beautiful settings and characters that perfectly match the bleak tone.

The story itself is flawless. It begins with Bruce realizing that he no longer feels grief over his parents' death (because of it being so long ago), which gives him an existential crisis about why he's still Batman. After maybe seeing the ghosts of his parents, who were disappointed with his life since they wanted him safe and happy, he says to Alfred that if they were real, he would quit being Batman. Alfred calls bs and says a great quote:

>"You cast your life to a purpose, regardless of the catalyst, Bruce. Simply put, you are the Batman because it is who you are meant to be."

Meanwhile, the other side of the story shows Nyssa, Ra's al Ghul's first daughter, who is many centuries old and has seen the worst of humanity, from slavery to the Holocaust. Unlike Bruce, she lets the outside world decide who she is, and becomes even more misanthropic than her father.

Aside from those parallel arcs, the main plot (in the current day) is a great thriller and ties the two together.

I really wish more was done with Nyssa as a League of Assassins that had no respect for Batman like Ra's does would be so cool. I feel like it would be much more of a threat.

reddit.com
u/Fun_Air_2527 — 17 days ago
▲ 8 r/batman

Since Jason is Robin for The Cult, it takes place in year seven too.

I think it's pretty hard to compete with Knightfall even on its own, which has Bruce going through a mental and physical downward spiral just to have Bane break out all of Arkham, and then once Bruce has dealt with all of that, he gets put through the gauntlet of Bane's followers and finally, after all that his back is broken (in his own home!) and Bane brings him the centre of Gotham just to shame him even more. And then of course there's what happened with Shondra Kinsolving (Bruce's love interest at the time) and eventually Azrael...

I guess you could consider year eleven as well, which I think is entirely No Man's Land, but it came out after this timeline. Having Gotham abandoned by the government and filled with criminals as well as Sarah Essen's death definitely make it worth considering.

u/Fun_Air_2527 — 24 days ago
▲ 77 r/batman_comics+1 crossposts

In general I think people confuse the violence of Arkham Batman with comic Batman quite a lot. Of course there’s been lots of interpretations (like TDKR), but the point Knightfall makes about Batman being a true hero, not an anti-hero should be significant enough to form the main interpretation of him.

Knightfall suit mod for Arkham Knight.

u/Fun_Air_2527 — 26 days ago