Not sure if this is allowed for Memorial Day: My 5th Great Gtandfather, George W. Hoffman.

Not sure if this is allowed for Memorial Day: My 5th Great Gtandfather, George W. Hoffman.

He mustered in Co. E, 15th West Virginia Infantry on September 10, 1862. He would later be absent sick in Grafton, Ohio on July 10, 1863, where he would miss Operations against Robert E. Lee, who was retreating from Gettysburg. He returned in September. He went back into Hospital in May 1864, right as his regiment started seeing combat, and later died of Pneumonia on January 22, 1865. His time was entirely spent on the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad, and never saw combat.

He appears on a “Descriptive lists of deserters arrested”, in which he was arrested on October 25, 1864 for overstaying a furlough. He appears on a “descriptive list of deserters” on January 19, 1865, for again overstaying a furlough.

30 years later, Francis Hoffman wrote a letter dated April 20, 1894 to the editors of the Morgantown Journal in regards to Elijah's obituary. In which he included George as one of the five brothers who "wore the blue in defense of this glorious Union of ours." A record he was proud of. Albeit, he got George's wrong, listing it as the 5th WV Infantry, not the 15th.

Out of the 5 Hoffman brothers to serve in the Union Army, he was the only one that died. Meanwhile, his brother, Lt. Nimrod N. Hoffman fought with the 1st West Virginia Cavalry. And Francis Marion Hoffman of the 3rd West Virginia Infantry was wounded at the Second Battle of Bull Run, resulting in leg amputation.

Given how he never saw combat and was apparently a deserter, I’m unsure if I’m allowed to mention him for Memorial Day.

u/GenZ_Nathaniel — 16 days ago

Does my ancestor deserve to be mentioned on Memorial Day?

My 5th great grandfather mustered in the Union Army on September 10, 1862. He basically sat around the B&O railroad for 2½ years while the real Army actually fought the enemy. He first went into hospital in Grafton, Ohio on July 10, 1863 and missed some operations against General Lee. He went into hospital again in May 1864 and later died of Pneumonia in January 20, 1865.

A few points:

  1. He was mentioned on a “Descriptive list of Deserters arrested” on September 25, 1864 at Gallipolis Hospital, and arrested on October 25, 1864 for failing to return from furlough. He deserted again while on Furlough on January 19, 1865. So he’s clearly a deserter.

  2. He never saw any combat.

reddit.com
u/GenZ_Nathaniel — 19 days ago

Does my ancestor deserve to be mentioned on Memorial Day?

My 5th great grandfather mustered in the Union Army on September 10, 1862. He basically sat around the B&O railroad for 2½ years while the real Army actually fought the enemy. He went into hospital in Grafton, Ohio on July 10, 1863. And missed some operations against General Lee. He went into hospital again in May 1864 and later died of Pneumonia in January 20, 1865.

A few points:

  1. He was mentioned on a “Descriptive list of Deserters arrested” on September 25, 1864 at Gallipolis Hospital, and arrested on October 25, 1864 for failing to return from furlough. He deserted again while on Furlough on January 19, 1865. So he’s clearly a deserter.

  2. He never saw any combat.

reddit.com
u/GenZ_Nathaniel — 19 days ago
▲ 7 r/lonely

I’m gonna die alone.

just saw a post by u/sand_bitch about some lovey dovey bs with his gf and it tipped me over the edge.

I’m really gonna die alone. There’s no redeemable qualities about me. I’m 22, unemployed, still live with my mom, broke, no drivers license, ugly as shit. Just undesirable in every sense of the word.

reddit.com
u/GenZ_Nathaniel — 26 days ago

I only have 5 ancestors that were “Union” in the civil war. 2 were in the 14th Kentucky Cavalry:

One

- Mustered in April 1, 1863

- “Absent sick” for four months (May-August 1863)

- “Not Stated” in September and October (although apparently appeared on an “muster in roll” in October)

- Discharged on March 24, 1864.

The Second:

- Mustered in September 19, 1862

- Reenlisted February 28, 1863

- “Not stated” March - April 1863

- “Charge for desertion preferred” May - October 1863

- Mustered out March 24, 1864

It’s probably worth noting that June, July, and August were the regiments most active phase, engaging in skirmishes against raids from Col. John Scott and Capt. Peter Everett, they just “happen” to miss them.

The problem is that there’s no documentation proving that they ever returned before muster out. So that’s what leads to my question, what are the odds that they just abandoned the Union for months, then just squeezed back in last second before mustering out?

I imagine a scenario where they faked or exaggerated an illness, or just ran away all together, went AWOL for months, then showed back up just in time for muster out.

reddit.com
u/GenZ_Nathaniel — 1 month ago