Image 1 — A few things I want to add to this post I saw recently.
Image 2 — A few things I want to add to this post I saw recently.
Image 3 — A few things I want to add to this post I saw recently.

A few things I want to add to this post I saw recently.

  1. Correction: Daniel Morgan won Cowpens, not Nathanael Greene as the first photo implies.

  2. The race to the Dan was really just Cornwallis being incredibly pompous and brash more than Greene being a “genius."

  3. Cornwallis didn't "technically hold the field", he held the field. Period. Regardless of how you want to put it, Greene ran away, and that's a British victory by default.

  4. One thing that deserves to be mentioned is my ancestor's regiment, the 1st Maryland Regiment, took part in all this, and it actively soiled their image and legacy. The regiment had saved Washington's Army at Long Island, and took part in the battles of Trenton, Princeton, and Cowpens. Instead of being allowed to go out with a victory, Greene reduced them to constant retreats and losses in the South, including Guilford.

No o hate towards the original poster is intended, I'm just adding my 2 cents.

u/GenZ_Nathaniel — 10 days ago

If your ancestor fought at Yorktown, I envy you.

My ancestor was part of the 1st Maryland regiment from 1776 until his discharge in 1783. I used to think he fought at Yorktown, but then I found out from his pension application that he actually wasn’t.

If your ancestor fought at Yorktown. Just know that I’m jealous. Your ancestors contributed way more to the founding of America than mine, and you have far more to be proud of.

u/GenZ_Nathaniel — 1 month ago

Despite being “one of the best regiment” in the Revolution, the 1st Maryland was not allowed to take part in the Siege of Yorktown in 1781.

u/GenZ_Nathaniel — 1 month ago

It’s funny how the regiment that quite literally saved Washington and his Army at the Battle of Long Island, and is described as “one of the best and most dependable” and “relied heavily upon” was excluded from the Siege of Yorktown in 1781.

I only care because my ancestor was part of the 1st Maryland Regiment from 1775 until 1783.

u/GenZ_Nathaniel — 1 month ago

Paintings of the 1st Maryland Regiment at the Battle of Guilford Courthouse on March 15, 1781. Details below.

The 1st Maryland Regiment is said to have been one of the best regiments of the American Revolution. They distinguished themselves at the Battle of Long Island when 400 members of the regiment repeatedly charged British forces, buying George Washington enough time to evacuate his troops to Manhattan. This action is what gave the State of Maryland the nickname “The Old Line State.”

They later fought at the Battles of White Plains, Trenton, Princeton, Brandywine, Germantown, and Monmouth, Camden, and Cowpens.

However, Despite being one of “Washington’s best regiments”, they did not participate in the glory of the Siege of Yorktown. They were instead reduced to constant loses at the Guilford Courthouse, Ninety Six, and Eutaw Springs, Ninety Six, and Eutaw Springs, in which always ended in being ordered to run away and hand over an easy win to the British.

My ancestor fought in this regiment for the entire war, and it’s a real shame they didn’t go out with a victory.

u/GenZ_Nathaniel — 1 month ago
▲ 20 r/BattlePaintings+1 crossposts

Painting of the 1st Maryland Regiment at the Battle of Guilford Courthouse on March 15, 1781 by Frederick C. Yohn.

The 1st Maryland Regiment is said to have been one of the best regiments of the American Revolution. They distinguished themselves at the Battle of Long Island when 400 members of the regiment repeatedly charged British forces, buying George Washington enough time to evacuate his troops to Manhattan. This action is what gave the State of Maryland the nickname “The Old Line State.”

They later fought at the Battles of White Plains, Trenton, Princeton, Brandywine, Germantown, and Monmouth, Camden, and Cowpens.

However, Despite being one of “Washington’s best regiments”, they did not participate in the glory of the Siege of Yorktown. They were instead reduced to constant loses at the Guilford Courthouse, Ninety Six, and Eutaw Springs, Ninety Six, and Eutaw Springs, in which always ended in being ordered to run away and hand over an easy win to the British.

My ancestor fought in this regiment for the entire war, and it’s a real shame they didn’t go out with a victory.

u/GenZ_Nathaniel — 10 days ago

Can my civil war ancestors be considered “Union”?

I’m not really sure that their duties were, but I know for a fact they saw no combat. The Kentucky guys MAY have patrolled Eastern Kentucky for confederate bushwhackers, the West Virginia ones MAY have “guarded” the B&O railroad, but I’ve found no evidence to prove they personally did these things, it’s an educational guess.

u/GenZ_Nathaniel — 3 months ago

My 5th Great Grandfather (left) ca. 1863. He joined the Union Army in September 1862 and “served” for a total of 1 year and 5 months doing nothing but guarding railroads. He was also a deserter, listed as such twice for overstaying furlough before he died of pneumonia in 1865. He never saw combat.

u/GenZ_Nathaniel — 3 months ago

Why does my Civil War ancestor have a military headstone despite being a deserter?

He appears twice on a “list of deserters arrested” for overstaying a furlough, once in October 1864 and again in January 1865. Yet he still has a military headstone.

reddit.com
u/GenZ_Nathaniel — 3 months ago

Someone’s changing the result of the Battle of Guilford Courthouse. Does this count as vandalism?

It use to just say “British Victory” until someone changed it to “see aftermath.” They changed it back one I tried editing it. The British held the field once Greene ran away, by default, that’s a British Victory. Why is it such a bad thing to call it such?

u/GenZ_Nathaniel — 3 months ago
▲ 137 r/AmericanHistory+1 crossposts

Someone’s changing the result of the Battle of Guilford Courthouse.

It use to just say “British Victory” until someone changed it to “see result.” They changed it back one I tried editing it. The British held the field once Greene ran away, by default, that’s a British Victory. Why is it such a bad thing to call it such?

en.wikipedia.org
u/GenZ_Nathaniel — 1 month ago
▲ 66 r/extremelyinfuriating+2 crossposts

My 5th Great Grandfather (left) died of pneumonia in 1865 without ever having fought against the Confederacy during the Civil War.

His name was George Washington Hoffman. He joined the 15th West Virginia Infantry in September 1862. He was sick in hospital for a brief period in July 1863 and missed operations against Robert E. Lee who was retreating from Gettysburg. He returned some time in August and was present until he went into hospital AGAIN in May 1864, right as his regiment started to engage in combat. He died of Pneumonia on January 22, 1865 without ever seeing combat. His time was spent entirely on the Baltimore and Ohio railroad.

His regiment was later at Appomattox Courthouse, where Robert E. Lee surrendered (granted, there contribution was very limited)

u/GenZ_Nathaniel — 3 months ago
▲ 56 r/revolutionarywar+2 crossposts

Basically every battle Nathanael Greene fought.

I know I already posted, but I thought this was better.

u/GenZ_Nathaniel — 3 months ago