Is it only me who thinks that our coaching staff is built only on the basis of nostalgia and loyalty
Going back to 2025, we brought in Mahela Jayawardene again to recreate 2017, 2019, and 2020, but it seems like nothing fell into place. He made statements like “180 is a par score at Wankhede,” did not know how to adapt to the impact player rule on multiple separate occasions, and we used 24 out of 25 players, which is a result of him fucking up at the 2025 auction. Plus, he did not even give chances to youngsters like Mayank Rawat and Izhar, even at the end of the season.
Coming onto Malinga and Pollard, I feel it is more out of respect, especially when it comes to Pollard, because you retired him after 2022 and he continued to play other leagues, and Malinga because he was our bowling spearhead. But from my perspective, they are not coaching material. They can give you a bit of guidance regarding their craft, but Robin Singh and Shane Bond were much better because they worked with us for so long. But it is shocking now that one was sacked and went to RR, and the other has left all MI franchises. Just why??
Moreover, even though one can say that our players have been in abysmal form and, due to the bad team environment, everybody’s performance goes down, the management has shat the bed a lot. Our scouting has downgraded so much from 2024. I have not seen a good scouted pick other than Naman Dhir. Our other youngsters are Robin Minz, Malewar, Bhagat, Bawa, and Ashwani, who is also very inconsistent, while other teams have brought in Sakib, Vaibhav Suryavanshi, Aniket Verma, Prince Yadav, and Angkrish Raghuvanshi for such low prices, so money should not be an excuse. It is very sad because our previous history shows we have scouted the Pandya brothers, Bumrah, Tilak, Ishan, Stubbs, etc.
Let’s look at the case study of RCB. They brought in one of the most successful T20 franchise coaches, Andy Flower. They also made Mo Bobat Director of Cricket, who won the 2019 50-over World Cup and the 2022 T20 World Cup with the England national team as a performance director. Even DK, with his mentorship and analysis, has helped RCB in the auction. These are people that understand the modern T20 template and have very good planning when it comes to everything.
So my final opinion is that we also need a complete overhaul in our coaching setup get in fresh names like adam vogues, ashwin , eoin morgan, jonathan trott etc because now even csk fans have started talking about sacking fleming because of how ouddated he has become but we have been worse than them since last 6 years therefore we need a new coaching staff more desperately .