A genuine question about identity, nationalism, and China among some Northeast Indians.
​
I've been noticing a trend on social media, especially Instagram, where some people seem quick to criticize India while defending China. This is something I've seen particularly among a section of Northeast Indians, and I'm genuinely curious about the reasons behind it.
Before anyone misunderstands me, I'm not saying India is perfect. India has many problems—poverty, corruption, infrastructure gaps, racism, and countless other issues that still need to be addressed. We have a long way to go in many areas.
However, one thing I appreciate is that India's problems are generally visible and openly discussed. The media, social media, and public discourse regularly expose both the good and the bad. In contrast, China has historically exercised much tighter control over information. Many international platforms are blocked, domestic platforms dominate the online space, and the image presented to the outside world is often heavily curated. As a result, many of China's internal problems receive far less global attention than India's.
What I find interesting is that when people start pointing out China's shortcomings—whether related to transparency, censorship, economic issues, or social problems—some individuals immediately rush to defend China while being extremely critical of India.
Admiring another country's achievements is perfectly fine. China has undoubtedly made remarkable progress in infrastructure, manufacturing, poverty reduction, and technological development. There is a lot India can learn from those successes.
But no country is flawless. China has its own problems, just as India does. Racism, discrimination, inequality, and social challenges exist everywhere in different forms.
Sometimes I get the impression that a few people romanticize China while being unwilling to acknowledge its flaws. At the same time, they focus almost exclusively on India's shortcomings. I don't think either approach is balanced.
India is an incredibly diverse country with hundreds of ethnic groups, languages, cultures, and religions. Managing such diversity is naturally complicated, and challenges are inevitable. That doesn't excuse our problems, but it does provide context.
I believe it's possible to be proud of India while also being honest about its weaknesses. Likewise, it's possible to admire aspects of China without treating it as a perfect model.
I'm genuinely interested in hearing perspectives from Northeast Indians and others. Is this perception accurate, or am I simply seeing a vocal minority online?
What find ironic is that when people start criticizing China in the same way China has often criticized India, some of the loudest defenders seem to come from certain Northeast Indian circles. Why??