Just Connecting Dots
●In tv shows featuring both Rituals and demons and monster... The order is hardly Demon first Rituals second.
Rituals come first before the evil.
●Rituals are done by people who know magic. Typically witches.
●Tabitha had a doll that gave a man nightmares. Not only that but Tabitha posses memories of killing magical creatures. She knew what the skull poles were used for. She was most likely the witch who invented it. If Tabitha knew magic that protected from magical creatures, then she most likely made the talismans as well.
But where did the magical creatures come from in the first place? You might ask. Well lets connect more dots.
● Jade and Tabitha had a daughter sometime unknown before the Christopher and Miranda cycle. But they never revealed who the daughter was. They remember the town, they remember the children, symbols etc but not even so much as a face of their daughter and coincidentally neither of the MIY whos there every cycle.
● We know the magic in town isn't all evil. I doubt monsters go through bottle trees or make talismans. We also know that Jade and Tabitha are reincarnating for the sake of SAVING. (Stoping the cycle) I don't think the evil brings Jade and Tabitha back. Heres why.
● previous Jade drank blood from a skull. That is a ritual definitely. But if his lore is trying to free children and free the residents of Fromville then whatever came of the ritual he participated in most likely aligns with that goal. If Tabitha and Jade were together and Tabitha knew magic. Then it makes sense Tabitha performed the magic that brings them back failed attempt after failed attempt.
So my conclusion after connecting these dots:
Tabitha was a witch who dated Jade. They had a daughter who also came out a witch but evil. (MIY)
Ofc my theory can only cover so much ground. I dont got it all figured out but I do know 98% sure of it... Tabitha is a witch and is somehow responsible for how the evil of Fromville started to begin with.