u/Guilty_Pirate6036

After spending way too much time tweaking Commander decks, I ended up building a website that tries to evaluate deck quality automatically. It also gives you the opportunity to compare decks in your POD and to create new ones.

You paste a decklist and it analyzes:

- mana curve

- ramp

- card draw

- removal

- combo signals

- strong cards

Here you can see my vivi deck example:

https://www.ratemydecks.com/en/deck/e87b4cc21efb

The goal isn’t to replace playtesting obviously, but to help catch issues while brewing.

I’d love honest feedback from EDH players:

- Is the analysis useful?

- What feels wrong?

- What metrics matter most to you when building?

Website:

https://www.ratemydecks.com

Also curious:

what’s the #1 mistake you see most Commander players make when deckbuilding?