u/Guinso

Hello everyone,

Progressive is my current car insurance company and I've been with them for 4 years now. It is set to renew for another 6 months next week and I went shopping (GEICO & Costco Auto Insurance / American Family) but for some reason GEICO came wildly cheaper than both my current insurance and American Family. Basically half of what I am paying.

Could you all please just take a look and confirm I am indeed comparing apples to apples? Coverage seems the same to my inexperienced eyes.

I'm located in the suburbs of Atlanta, GA. Thank you all for the help!

Imgur link with price for both insurances: https://imgur.com/a/6DkukGx