In my opinion Gluttony for punishment is way easier and depends less on luck than lookerless. There’s some badges that are rarer, sure, but most of them are new, so of course not many people got them. But these badges been there since forever.
I just decided to play with randoms for the first time and this what I got
The ridge was the most terrifying part, I’m not exaggerating. I swear to god the last door of the ridge a walldweller just spawned beside me while I was waiting for an angler to come. I didn’t see the walldweller but heard it so I was looking around, hoping I see it, so it won’t kill me (because last time I died to it in the same spot in the ridge) but as it went closer, a blitz came out of nowhere and thank god I pressed the square on my controller so fast, I swear I almost had a heart attack from the stress. I screamed for a whole minute when I got this badge.
The first try I did correctly, but the game for some reason didn’t count (even though I didn’t revive, did flash eyefestation in the door 76, and didn’t rescue Painter) so I had to do it again.
My tips? Play with a controller, it’s way easier. And play it safe in the ridge, even if it takes you ten minutes (like I had)