▲ 1 r/mtgrules
Can I activate Ashnod’s Altar to generate mana in response to discarding a card with madness?
I’m wondering about the following situation:
1.) I have Ashnod’s Altar in play and three thopter tokens on the board.
2.) I cast Discerning Riddler, which has the text, “When this creature enters, you may discard a card. If you do, draw a card.“ I discard Emrakul, the World Anew, which has Madness 6.
3.) I sacrifice my three thopters to generate 6 colorless mana.
4.) I cast Emrakul, the World Anew with the 6 colorless mana.
5.) I then draw a card and the Riddler’s ETB resolves.
Would I be able to Ashnod’s Altar in the middle of that ETB’s resolution? My concern is that since the discard happens before the ETB has finished resolving, I wouldn’t be able to activate Ashnod’s Altar in the middle of it all.
u/HappyGlobe — 1 day ago