u/Head-Web6201

I made a post yesterday about a vanilla/tonka formula I'm working on that would be close to Vanille Planifolia with added tonka and resins. Some people thought it was an AI formula because I used 2 key accords from Perfumers Apprentice and thought it would be a good idea to expand them into their individual components to show you the full formula, which resulted in some materials having very precise percentages. It's not AI, I'm just an accountant who enjoys numbers lol

Anyway, this is my redemption where I post the actual formula instead of the expanded one. If any of you have a moment, I would really appreciate your feedback as well as any guidance on how to carry the dark vanilla/tonka identity to the heart/top. I made a 25% dilution and the longevity is great but the projection is moderate, similar to Spiritueuse Double Vanille.

12% PA Vanilla Bean Accord
9% Iso E Super
9% Hedione HC
8% PA Tonka Bean Accord
6% Habanolide
4.5% Methyl Ionone
4.5% Exaltolide Total
4% Ethyl Vanillin
3% Benzoin 50% Alc.
3% Ethylene Brassylate
3% Benzyl Salicylate
3% Sandalore
2% Vanilla Absolute 50% in BB
2% Ambergris T Oliffac
2% Labdanum 50%
2% Heliotropex N
2% Ambrettolide
2% Cedarwood Atlas Oil
2% Tonka Bean Absolute 50% Alc.
2% Vanillin 10% Alc.
1.5% Amber Dioxane
1.5% Isobutavan
1.5% Ambrox Super
1.5% Cashmeran
1% Peru Balsam
1% Maltol 10%
1% Bergamot EO
1% Apricot Essence Natural Fragrance
1% Azarbre
1% Benzaldehyde 50% in BB
0.5% Javanol
0.5% Muscenone
0.5% Zingerone 10%
0.5% Patchouli Fractions
0.4% Rhumacetal
0.4% Ethyl Acetate 10% in BB
0.2% Pink Pepper SFE

I made a post yesterday about a vanilla/tonka formula I'm working on that would be close to Vanille Planifolia with added tonka and resins. Some people thought it was an AI formula because I used 2 key accords from Perfumers Apprentice and thought it would be a good idea to expand them into their individual components to show you the full formula, which resulted in some materials having very precise percentages. It's not AI, I'm just an accountant who enjoys numbers lol

Anyway, this is my redemption where I post the actual formula instead of the expanded one. If any of you have a moment, I would really appreciate your feedback as well as any guidance on how to carry the dark vanilla/tonka identity to the heart/top. I made a 25% dilution and the longevity is great but the projection is moderate, similar to Spiritueuse Double Vanille.

12% PA Vanilla Bean Accord
9% Iso E Super
9% Hedione HC
8% PA Tonka Bean Accord
6% Habanolide
4.5% Methyl Ionone
4.5% Exaltolide Total
4% Ethyl Vanillin
3% Benzoin 50% Alc.
3% Ethylene Brassylate
3% Benzyl Salicylate
3% Sandalore
2% Vanilla Absolute 50% in BB
2% Ambergris T Oliffac
2% Labdanum 50%
2% Heliotropex N
2% Ambrettolide
2% Cedarwood Atlas Oil
2% Tonka Bean Absolute 50% Alc.
2% Vanillin 10% Alc.
1.5% Amber Dioxane
1.5% Isobutavan
1.5% Ambrox Super
1.5% Cashmeran
1% Peru Balsam
1% Maltol 10%
1% Bergamot EO
1% Apricot Essence Natural Fragrance
1% Azarbre
1% Benzaldehyde 50% in BB
0.5% Javanol
0.5% Muscenone
0.5% Zingerone 10%
0.5% Patchouli Fractions
0.4% Rhumacetal
0.4% Ethyl Acetate 10% in BB
0.2% Pink Pepper SFE

Hi everyone,
Long-time lurker here. I spent the past few weeks developing and tinkering with some of the ACs I have to create a dark gourmand vanilla and tonka perfume with resinous, woody and musky facets. I envisioned a mix of Vanille Planifolia and Spiritueuse Double Vanille, with a lot of added tonka, a juicy top note, and better projection and longevity. I ended up with this formula and would truly appreciate some feedback based on your expertise. I have learned a lot from all of you over the years, but I am very far from being an expert, so any guidance in how to make the vanilla/tonka perfume of my dreams would be greatly appreciated.
P.S: All of the materials are from Perfumers Apprentice, and I used a couple of bases from there that I broke down into their individual components for clarity, which explains the trace percentages at the bottom and some of the redundancy in the materials.
Thank you in advance!

9% Iso E Super
9% Hedione HC
6.4787% Benzyl Benzoate
6.4398% Ethyl Vanillin
6% Habanolide
4.5% Methyl Ionone
4.5% Exaltolide Total
4.3366% Alcohol from dilutions
4.32% Propylene Glycol
3% Ethylene Brassylate
3% Benzyl Salicylate
3% Sandalore
2.4% Hedione
2% Ambergris T Oliffac
2% Heliotropex N
2% Ambrettolide
2% Cedarwood Atlas Oil
1.7963% DPG
1.5927% Bicyclononalactone
1.5927% Coumarin
1.5299% Benzoin Resinoid
1.5% Amber Dioxane
1.5% Isobutavan
1.5% Ambrox Super
1.5% Cashmeran
1.4% Vanillin
1.2% Methyl Diantilis
1.01% TEC
1% Labdanum
1% Vanilla Absolute
1% Tonka Bean Absolute
1% Peru Balsam
1% Bergamot EO
1% Apricot Essence Natural Fragrance
1% Azarbre
0.5% Benzaldehyde
0.5% Javanol
0.5% Muscenone
0.5% Patchouli Fractions
0.4% Rhumacetal
0.2% Pink Pepper SFE
0.1% Maltol
0.05% Zingerone
0.048% Ethyl Maltol
0.04% Ethyl Acetate
0.0398% Heliotropin
0.0159% Anisic Aldehyde
0.0064% Tonka Feves Absolute Synthetic
0.0016% Methyl Laitone
0.0015% Tonka Feves Hyperessence
0.0001% Guaiacol

Hi everyone,
Long-time lurker here. I spent the past few weeks developing and tinkering with some of the ACs I have to create a dark gourmand vanilla and tonka perfume with resinous, woody and musky facets. I envisioned a mix of Vanille Planifolia and Spiritueuse Double Vanille, with a lot of added tonka, a juicy top note, and better projection and longevity. I ended up with this formula and would truly appreciate some feedback based on your expertise. I have learned a lot from all of you over the years, but I am very far from being an expert, so any guidance in how to make the vanilla/tonka perfume of my dreams would be greatly appreciated.
P.S: All of the materials are from Perfumers Apprentice, and I used a couple of bases from there that I broke down into their individual components for clarity, which explains the trace percentages at the bottom and some of the redundancy in the materials.
Thank you in advance!

9% Iso E Super
9% Hedione HC
6.4787% Benzyl Benzoate
6.4398% Ethyl Vanillin
6% Habanolide
4.5% Methyl Ionone
4.5% Exaltolide Total
4.3366% Alcohol from dilutions
4.32% Propylene Glycol
3% Ethylene Brassylate
3% Benzyl Salicylate
3% Sandalore
2.4% Hedione
2% Ambergris T Oliffac
2% Heliotropex N
2% Ambrettolide
2% Cedarwood Atlas Oil
1.7963% DPG
1.5927% Bicyclononalactone
1.5927% Coumarin
1.5299% Benzoin Resinoid
1.5% Amber Dioxane
1.5% Isobutavan
1.5% Ambrox Super
1.5% Cashmeran
1.4% Vanillin
1.2% Methyl Diantilis
1.01% TEC
1% Labdanum
1% Vanilla Absolute
1% Tonka Bean Absolute
1% Peru Balsam
1% Bergamot EO
1% Apricot Essence Natural Fragrance
1% Azarbre
0.5% Benzaldehyde
0.5% Javanol
0.5% Muscenone
0.5% Patchouli Fractions
0.4% Rhumacetal
0.2% Pink Pepper SFE
0.1% Maltol
0.05% Zingerone
0.048% Ethyl Maltol
0.04% Ethyl Acetate
0.0398% Heliotropin
0.0159% Anisic Aldehyde
0.0064% Tonka Feves Absolute Synthetic
0.0016% Methyl Laitone
0.0015% Tonka Feves Hyperessence
0.0001% Guaiacol