u/Heavy_Rhubarb6554

What do you think about the "A Light in the Piazza" musical?

What do you think about the "A Light in the Piazza" musical?

So I'm a big theater guy, and I was going to listen to the "A Light in the Piazza" soundtrack. I did a bit of research on the story, and I tried to see what the disabled community often thinks about its depictions of disabled people, as one of the main characters, Clara, was kicked in the head by a pony as a kid, resulting in slowed intellectual and emotional development. She is 26 in the time of the musical. I found some mixed opinions about the ethics of consent and the representation of disabilities in it (although it was unclear whether those opinions came from disabled people, so they might not be the best sources). So I thought I'd ask you all.

Here is Wikipedia's description of it: "Based on the 1960 novella by Elizabeth Spencer, the show is set in the 1950s and tells the story of Margaret Johnson, a wealthy woman from the American South, and Clara, her daughter, who is developmentally disabled due to a childhood accident. The two spend a summer together in Florence, Italy. When Clara falls in love with a young Italian man, Fabrizio, Margaret is forced to reconsider not only Clara's future, but her own deep-seated hopes and regrets as well" (The Light in the Piazza (musical) - Wikipedia). Clara ends up marrying Fabrizio at the end.

I haven't actually seen the show or listened to it besides a few songs, just a bit of research. Is it problematic in any way? I appreciate your help!

u/Heavy_Rhubarb6554 — 10 days ago

Which of these is the best for a different term for "Special Education"

Hello!

I've been lurking in this sub for a bit now and have seen some great insights. I'm interested in working with people with disabilities, including as a career, specifically those with intellectual and cognitive disabilities. I'm currently 15 btw and am still learning a lot lol.

I know terms like "special needs" and "special education" can be very offensive and patronizing. I took a class last year where I was partnered with students with disabilities in the adaptive education programs at my school, and while the programs are officially under the branch of "special education" in my county, I wanted to find a replacement for the label that is inclusive and inoffensive.

I know there are some posts on here asking similar things, but I wanted to find the generally preferred term. I took some ideas from those posts and my own research to make a list of label possibilities:

  • Adaptive ed. (this is one I'm leaning towards, but my opinion is secondhand as I'm not disabled)
  • Accessible education
  • Accommodated ed.
  • Disability support ed.
  • Learning support ed.
  • Additional support needs ed.

Although I wonder, because most of the people in these programs in school have intellectual or cognitive disabilities, and people with solely physical ones are often in general ed., if some of these (like Disability Support Ed.) are too broad? Then again, "special education" isn't exactly descriptive either. Also, many of these terms seem like they could be used to refer to resources for people who have accommodations like extra time on tests but are in general ed. and not in mostly separate classes. Or even support like translators, English as a second language classes, or discounted school lunches. Basically, I'm wondering if these terms are specific enough and if/how we should differentiate those types of resources from the classes working with students with intellectual or cognitive disabilities. But maybe the broadness is good to move away from the binary of general ed vs adaptive ed. Correct me if I'm wrong tho. Ig even if they aren't super specific, they still seem better than "special ed."

In addition, I know there is much more to be done than renaming the system, and there are a lot of problems with accessibility in education. This is just one step.

Which one(s) here, or those outside of this list, are best?

Thank you all so much! I hope I worded everything right lol and didn't say anything offensive

Edit: I changed my paragraph about the broadness concern because my wording was rly confusing sorry!

reddit.com
u/Heavy_Rhubarb6554 — 2 months ago