I (23F) love my boyfriend (25M) but I don’t know how to move on from everything that happened in the beginning of our relationship
I (23F) met my boyfriend (25M) through work in 2022. At first we weren’t officially together, it was more of a talking stage/on-and-off situation. We stopped talking for around 6 months because of personal reasons, then eventually started talking again.
One thing that always bothered me from the beginning was that all of his exes looked very similar: blonde, white, blue eyes, etc. At the time I had dyed blonde hair even though I’m naturally brunette and tan. There was also a girl at work who looked exactly like his “type,” and during the months we stopped talking he ended up talking to and going out with her.
When we reconnected, I kept seeing her name pop up on his phone. He told me it “didn’t work out,” but from the messages I saw (with his permission) they seemed to genuinely enjoy each other. It made me question why he came back to me in the first place. Eventually he removed her and we moved on.
A few months later, he told me one night that he was “with his sister,” but the next morning I accidentally saw messages between him and another girl. Again, she looked exactly like his type. His explanation was that he met her online while checking out a site because Omegle was shutting down, and they “just started talking.”
After all of this I honestly stopped trying to fit into what I thought he wanted. I dyed my hair back to black and started being myself again. But years later, I still get triggered whenever I see girls who look like that. My brain immediately goes to “would he rather look at her?” and I end up feeling awful about myself.
The bigger issue happened in late 2023/early 2024 when I found out he had been sexting and cheating on me with men online while we were literally sleeping next to each other. We almost broke up over it. He apologized, begged me to stay, deleted social media, and genuinely changed a lot afterward. Since then he has honestly been a much better partner overall.
The problem is that I don’t know how to move on mentally. Even though it’s been over 2 years, I constantly wonder if there are hidden chats, deleted messages, or things I just don’t know about. Sometimes I bring it up because it still hurts me, but I can tell he’s exhausted by the topic and feels frustrated that we can’t fully move on.
What makes this harder is that I genuinely do see the effort and change in him now. I love him and can honestly see a future with him. But I also feel like the damage from the beginning permanently changed the way I think and trust.
His argument is that technically we “weren’t serious” until he officially asked me to be his girlfriend in 2024, even though emotionally I was already fully invested long before that.