u/Hot-Negotiation1543

I had a brand new item damaged (we are seller) that UPS paid out a full insurance replacement claim. The customer wanted a replacement, so i had to send him another one, which was a wash $ wise for me. Customer sent me back the damaged item. I have had it for probably 2 years now at home. It was damaged beyond being able to sell as new, but still worth something used. Can i sell it?