Canceling Song of the Wasteland was the right choice
So i thought I should bring this up since I've been seeing a lot of crazy takes online about the cancelation. I believe the cancelation was the RIGHT choice.
Before I start my rant as to why, dont start telling me I'm a "newgen" fan, ive been reading yaoi for 10 years now.
So as a citizen of the US, much of our history is based in slavery and all throughout school we learn about just how terrible it was. Not only do we learn about slavery of African Americans, but also the horrible mistreatment of native Americans (such as the trail of tears, the battle of horseshoe bend, etc) and seeing a manhwa that romanticized the relationship between a white man and someone who has been historically oppressed was frankly disturbing.
Many people that I've been seeing online have been stating "separate fiction vs reality" but I believe this is not applicable when it comes to stories using real history as a background (especially when its between a marginalized group and a oppressor). When you start to create fiction that romanticizes brutal history, it makes people take light of the situation and how deeply traumatic it was. For those who arent from the US, its like if someone wrote a romance between a Korean comfort wife and and a Japanese soldier where the Korean comfort wife ENJOYED being one, or a romance between a citizen of nanking and a Japanese soldier (during the rape of nanking), or a Russian soldier and a Ukrainian citizen, or a German soldier and a jew, the list goes on and on.
Furthermore, as a history major I just had to point out this inaccuracy. One of the main leads in the story is shown to be a man from a rich background that joined the civil war. However, during the civil war the likelihood of a wealthy man joining the war was very unlikely. During the civil war both the Union and the Confederacy allowed wealthy men to legally buy their way out of military service through "commutation" fees or by hiring substitutes. These substitutes ironically were often slaves or poor men. Essentially, the war was a poor man's fight.
I do believe that there is nuance to these types of stories (especially when it comes to noncon) however I believe its more straightforward when basing a story in history. Stories based in history need to be very careful about where they draw the line between straight up disrespect and fiction. It was the right move by JAXX to cancel the manhwa and tbh im surprised it even got the green light.
Taking all this into account, I do not believe harassing or sending death threats to JAXX was ok. Im glad that JAXX actually understood the criticism and hope they can do a bit more research and approach these historical topics more carefully next time (as well as all other authors).
As for the readers, I find it crazy that people online are still defending this manhwa and saying that it should have been developed. Please familiarize yourself about the horrible mistreatment and genocide that was inflicted onto marginalized groups within the US before stating that we should "separate fiction from reality."