Rape Capital Punishment and my opinion and your disagreement
First thanks for taking part in uncomfortable conversation and still being civil if you are here and being civil
second lets clear something in the back of my head I want capital punishment, but something is not 100% in their hence I am asking question
First lets look at rape itself, sex between 2 consented minors is considered rape should capital punishment be imposed even there (hence I hate blanket statement specially when the discussion is this serious)
next rape where victim is not killed ; assumption k huncha bhaney capital punishment is the harshest of the punishment and should only be reserved for the most heinous of crime and I will argue that this does not fit the criteria don't get me wrong I categorize rape as crime against humanity but morality ra philosophy bata aali tada gayara practicality ko barey ni sochnu parcha punishment should not only to be to punish, it should be to protect others from falling to the same victim in future If someone is raping and the punishment for that is the same as murder then why would a criminal leave its victim alive at the very least if the punishment was not harsh enough then the life of victim can be saved (argument in USA's SC don't remember the case though) ........ also in the same category where victim is alive not all the rape is done by strangers there are multiple cases where the criminal is a relative aba if the punishment is death tya aauta family pressure not to tell create huncha denying any kind of justice whereas if the punishment was not so harsh then something could have been done Furthermore capital punishment in this case where victim lives can be linked to patriarchy and many would consider a setback on womens right as well, but that argument makes sense and doesn't at the same time for me so I am not going there
rape where victim is killed like todays case of 3 year old from my stance 100% should be given capital punishment but reality ma tesko ni lafda cha but since we are discussing if capital punishment should be allowed or not logistic and difficulty of it is irrelevant in this discussion
Now coming back to Capital Punishment itself I don't having it has ever reduced rape case anywhere at the very least not that I am aware of ....... Instead, from my perspective and the actual people that work in the field, having strict punishment bhanda ni effective chai having strong capability to catch the criminal chai is a stronger deterrent to stop such crime (there is a big likelihood that you will not commit a crime if you are more likely to be caught then if there were only stricter punishment) look at India they have capital punishment.......proven absolutely useless
Do you remember election time ma Sobita Gautam ko aauta vid was going viral where she said rape is not that serious of a crime and victim can recover and join the society and the outrage surrounding that ....... that is the real issue until society learns to accept victim they will not come out and since they will not come out the criminal will have a short of like insurance to commit the crime
3-4 din bata yo topic is poping up but I can't really reach an conclusion hence sharing thought hope you all keep the conversation civil