u/IAmMeButWhoAreYou7

Tied between Crash and Under the Table and dreaming, both 9.9/10 albums, peak Dave Matthews Band the only miss in both of those albums is proudest monkey on Crash and all the other songs make up for it
Before These Crowded Streets. Nearly fucking perfect album, just not as good as Crash and UTTAD. Has nearly no misses other than like 1 or 2 9.8/10
Come Tomorrow, Very very close to being with Before These Crowded Streets, just had some songs that aren't as good as others whereas Before these crowded streets has less of those heavily overhated and underrated 9.75/10
Busted Stuff, this album is peak. It has my 2 favorite songs by Dave Matthews Band in it (being Grace Is Gone and You Never Know) such an amazing and awesome album that deserves all the praise it gets 9.7/10
Stand Up, it is also so neck and neck with Busted Stuff. It is such a good album and so overhated, I love how it is different from most albums and what they did on you might die trying and dreamgirl is amazing 9.5
Big Whisky and the GrooGrux King and Away From the World, these two albums are tied because they are very similar and I intertwine them a lot. They have some very very good songs on them like "Shake Me Like a Monkey" and "How I Am," but most songs don't hit like the other albums 9/10
Walk Around The Moon, This album is really good, it gets overshadowed and blindly hated sometimes. People see it as "unpolished" and one of their newer trashier albums but it has some really good songs on it
Everyday, had the potential to be good, it's just really not that good. I don't like what they did in this album at all. Most of the songs have way too much guitar and just sound bad 6/10

My Dave Matthews Band studio album rankings