u/Illustrious_Bread910

Hi, this question is probably for pakistani shia people because I'm sure this is a more cultural thing.

For people who listen/believe in the bibi fatima kahani manat I have a few questions. If I live alone and do a manat to listen to a kahani if something comes true, can I listen to it on my own on youtube? Is this sufficient or do I need to listen to it in a group or someone else reading it? Also, if I think I forgot to listen to a kahani for a few old manats, can I listen to it once to make up for a few potential missed ones?

I am scared of the consequences of not listening/reading the kahani after a manat.

Thanks, and please dont be judgmental.