How Much House Can We Realistically Afford? Looking for Honest Feedback on Our Budget
▲ 12 r/MortgageLoans+2 crossposts

How Much House Can We Realistically Afford? Looking for Honest Feedback on Our Budget

My wife and I are looking to buy our first home in the Hudson Valley/NYC commuter area and I’m trying to figure out what monthly housing payment is realistic for our situation.

I’ve attached a summary of our income, expenses, savings, and family situation.

A few questions:

  1. Based on our numbers, what monthly housing payment would you personally feel comfortable with?

  2. If you were in our position, would you buy now or wait a few years until daycare expenses are gone?

  3. How much emergency savings would you want to have left after closing?

  4. Am I missing any major expenses or risks that I’m not accounting for?

  5. For those with young kids, what percentage of your take-home pay goes toward housing, and do you feel comfortable with that percentage?

Happy to answer any questions or provide more information.

u/InevitablePainter410 — 2 days ago

Advice on building my own home

Looking for some advice/real world experiences from people in the Hudson Valley/Dutchess County area in New York, who have built their own home or acted as their own GC.

My fiancée and I are starting to seriously look into possibly buying land and building own own home, instead of buying an older house that needs major work. I work in high-end residential construction in NYC, so I have construction experience and would likely self manage a good portion of the project (if banks allowed of course)

We’re trying to get a realistic understanding of:

• How much cash/liquidity people actually needed upfront.

• What lenders required for down payment/reserves.

• Architect/engineering/permitting costs before loan approval.

• Construction-to-permanent loans and which local banks were easiest to work with?

• Acting as your own GC / owner-builder experiences.

• Septic + drilled well vs municipal utilities.

• What to look out for when buying land in the Hudson Valley.

• Hidden costs people didn’t expect

We’re likely looking at a modest but well built home, possibly around 2,000 sq ft with a walkout/daylight basement.

Would appreciate any advice, lessons learned, lender recommendations, lot recommendations, or “things you wish you knew before starting.”

Thanks in advance.

Update:
For reference, my bother does concrete work so we would be doing the foundation and excavation etc ourselves, as well as septic tank. I would be doing all interior carpentry and all flooring installs. All this would reduce overall cost a lot I would imagine.

reddit.com
u/InevitablePainter410 — 16 days ago

Advice on Building Your Own Home

Looking for some advice/real world experiences from people in the Hudson Valley/Dutchess County area in New York, who have built their own home or acted as their own GC.

My fiancée and I are starting to seriously look into possibly buying land and building own own home, instead of buying an older house that needs major work. I work in high-end residential construction in NYC, so I have construction experience and would likely self manage a good portion of the project (if banks allowed of course)

We’re trying to get a realistic understanding of:

• How much cash/liquidity people actually needed upfront.

• What lenders required for down payment/reserves.

• Architect/engineering/permitting costs before loan approval.

• Construction-to-permanent loans and which local banks were easiest to work with?

• Acting as your own GC / owner-builder experiences.

• Septic + drilled well vs municipal utilities.

• What to look out for when buying land in the Hudson Valley.

• Hidden costs people didn’t expect.

We’re likely looking at a modest but well built home, possibly around 2,000 sq ft with a walkout/daylight basement.

Would appreciate any advice, lessons learned, lender recommendations, lot recommendations, or “things you wish you knew before starting.”

Thanks in advance.

Update:
For reference, my bother does concrete work so we would be doing the foundation and excavation etc ourselves, as well as septic tank. I would be doing all interior carpentry and all flooring installs. All this would reduce overall cost a lot I would imagine.

reddit.com
u/InevitablePainter410 — 16 days ago

Looking for advice on what to update the heating system on an old house I’m buying.

It currently has forced air run on propane. No back up radiators. Only back up heat is a wood burning stove in the Living room.

What’s the most cost effective way to upgrade this? Ideally id love to a proper central air system for heat and cooling but my budget is tight as I have two kids under 2.

I’m thinking maybe a heat pump and ductless mini splits. Would I need a back up system for the severe winter months though? I’m thinking I would.

For context it’s a 2 bed 1 bath in Dutchess County NY.

One way or another I do plan upgrade the cooling as well in the next year or two.

Any advice is greatly appreciated 🙏

reddit.com
u/InevitablePainter410 — 1 month ago