After weeks of doubt and research what to buy?
A lil backstory, i have been using a carlsbro csd110 for 4 years which is when i started to learn drums. Now its starting to feel like a toy mainly because of shitty(relatively) samples, midi incompatibility when i connect to daw, pad feel, only open-closed setting hi-hat pedal, cymbal zones and little things that arent really worth mentioning. It isn't a bad kit, but i just feel like the things i mentioned above might be halting my progress(maybe just a skill issue).
So i looked up a few models and brands. Here are some things i took into consideration:
• hi-hat stand (variable hi-hat resistance with physical stand)
• acoustic feel (pad and cymbal feel)
• longevity (wanna use it for many years)
• sample quality (good noise make ears tingle)
• midi connectivity (daw compatibility {chokes,splashes etc.})
bonus:
• additional cymbal pad
• rimshot (i was really excited about this when i accidentally discovered this on a yamaha kit at the store)
**Considered Models:**
Since i want longevity i mainly took brands like yamaha and roland into account because i imagine they would last longer than others. Between those brands i checked out the cheapest models with physical hi-hat stands(this is pretty important to me). In my region the yamahas that are at the same range as rolands are much cheaper so i am stuck between the models.
• Yamaha DTX6K2X (2025$\~)
• Yamaha DTX6K5-M (2175$\~)
• Yamaha DTX6K3X (2285$\~)
**Mesh Heads:**
So im pretty sure i wanna go with a yamaha at this point. I would like the snare to be high tuned feel, toms to feel dead. Last mesh kit i tried(it was a roland but mesh is mesh i guess) i couldnt tune it down enough to make the toms dead as an acoustic. So when i play the mesh and then play acoustic i wouldnt be able to compensate for lack of rebound, so im pretty sceptical about the DTX6K5-M which is mesh.
**Silicone/Rubber?:**
I really liked the silicone snare pad's feel on the DTX6K2X and DTX6K3X but i dont like the look of the tom pads on the K2X and i dont know if its worth the 250$-ish price difference on the K3X for those snare-pad looking tom pads(which i think has 2 zones). Also the silicones arent tuneable like the mesh heads.
**Also:**
The store clerk said they could do 100-150$ discount if buying in store so those arent the final prices but looks like the price difference between the models will stay the same.
**Conclusion:**
If you have used/tried these models/brands and have any idea how they behave and feel please tell me about it. I am mainly concerned about the bounciness of mesh heads but would really like to play with pads that are closer to real size(kind of sick of looking at small rubber pads).
• Which one/ones do you prefer?
• Why or Why not?
• Other brands/models you are confident that fit the criteria and would be as good as these models for the reasons i have mentioned?
This is a very important purchase for me since i am a student and would like to use this kit for 5-7years, i want to have something i wont regret. So if i end up feeling like the +250$ i pay for the more expensive yamaha kit is worth i will but i just need to know if its worth it. Thank you.
**Ps:** I know that fellas on reddit aren't huge fans of big paragraphs so i apologize for the wall of text. I just want to explain my situation as best as possible.