Gore-Tex vs. Old School (non-breathable) rain jackets?
Like many Vancouverites, I've owned (and still own) a number of Gore-Tex jackets, that I use both for active purposes but also a lot of general everyday use. I always thought they were overhyped and not as great as they are marketed to be. I know they are very effective for specific uses, however, I don't think they are the ideal choice for general everyday (non-active) use - both from a cost/value perspective, but also even in terms of keeping you dry.
People act like Gore-Tex is this magic perfectly waterproof material, but it just hasn't felt like that for me (and I've owned many jackets of all price levels). I find them fine for light rain, but if it's legit raining out, it's only a matter of time before I stop feeling dry underneath. I know that sometimes the moisture is sweat, but I am quite certain that the jacket itself eventually becomes saturated and some amount of water seeps through eventually.
Recently bought a non-breathable older (and much cheaper) style design and it's definitely on a different level of waterproofness. It doesn't breathe much (or at all?) so it is much less useful for active purposes, but I actually prefer it for general everyday use on days where you legit want a waterproof jacket.
Anyone else feel the same? I have talked to a few other people seemed to have more positive Gore-Tex experiences than me, so I am curious to hear from people on both sides. I do periodically wash my jackets with the proper "tech wash" stuff and reapply the waterproof spray, etc. so I don't think that's my issue.
On a related note, I also find it funny how most standard Gore-Tex jackets only go down to your waist and your pants get soaked if it's legit raining...