Gummy Teeth (October Submission)
(Cw: gore)
“-and thank you again, Gale, for that cute example of an affordable costume!”
I walked downstairs to the sound of the news channel my father always had on discussing cheap costume ideas, the kid on screen wearing what looked like a robot costume hastily made from cardboard boxes and shoddily painted even faster.
It was Halloween, my favorite holiday of the year, and it was the last year I could trick-or-treat, my 18th birthday falling a few days later. Even though I could technically go trick-or-treating after I turned 18, it’s not something that’s really approved of by most people.
I reached the bottom of the stairs wearing my Dracula costume I had bought with money earned from my part-time job bussing tables, the void-black cape flowing dramatically behind me. I walked into the kitchen and saw my mother at the sink, and she turned around in mock horror as she saw me, throwing her hands to her mouth in exaggerated fashion.
“Oh no! A vampire, in my home? How ever did you get inside without an invitation?!” I rolled my eyes as she smiled and she stepped forward to adjust my collar.
“Now, we don’t have blood here, Mr. Dracula, but we do have some pizza on the stove there.” She turned back to finish washing the pizza cutter she had been scrubbing, her hands covered in bubbles tinted orange by the pizza sauce staining the blade.
“Am I taking Janey out this year, or is she going with her friends?” I asked, my stomach growling as I grabbed a paper plate and napkin from the counter, piling it clumsily with more than a few slices. Janey was my little sister by 4 years, and as much as I loved her, she was an iron ball and chain on Halloween.
“No, she’s going with her friends, Becca and Sean, I think their names are?” Mom grabbed a piece herself and followed me out to the living room, the news channel starting to read off candies to avoid this year.
“Ok, I kinda figured, I heard her mention it the other day but I wasn’t sure.” My mouth was full of pizza when I spoke, and I covered my mouth with the napkin I had grabbed as well.
On the television, the pretty blonde news reporter was reading out candy companies to avoid due to recalls. I only half paid attention as I ate, figuring it would all be off-brand candies like the previous year, and I was right. She listed a few I recognized, a couple off-brand Kit-Kats for incorrect labeling, one that sounded similar to a Ring Pop for allergens, and not to hand out anything from some company named Crazy something-or-other due to contamination from some accident. Mom gasped quietly at that last one as the pretty blonde reporter passed off to her colleague who started going over the weather for the night.
“Jesus. That poor guy. I hope that company treats his family well, otherwise they need to get their asses a good lawyer.” She muttered as she stood and started walking back towards the kitchen, returning a few minutes later with a bowl full of candy for trick-or-treaters coming to our house.
“Just pay attention to it before you eat anything, and if tastes bad, just spit it out.” She rattled off her warning just as she did every year, and turned on our porch light. I had completely forgot to check the time and I looked at the clock above the stove from the couch. 7:44.
“Oh shit, I’m late!!” I yelled as I ran to the kitchen and threw out my plate, my mother hypocritically calling after me to stop swearing. I shouted an apology as I grabbed the purple cloth bag near the back door and ran back up to the front door, giving my mom a quick hug as I ran out of the front door to see my friends standing on the lawn, talking to my father, a large and burly man, but kind as a teddy bear.
“Hey Dad!” I said as I slowed to a jog, waving to my two friends, Donny and Gerald. They waved and politely walked a short distance away so I could talk to my father before I left.
“Hey, kiddo, if you get any Milk Duds, save ‘em for me? You owe at least a little dad tax.” He smirked as he gave me a hug, much to my protesting. He finally let me go after what felt like far too long, and I ran over to my friends, excited but saddened, a bittersweet feeling as I went out for the last time.
Two hours and countless houses later, we sat on the floor of my living room, examining our haul. We had already taken off our costumes, just lounging around while some old unknown horror movie played on the television behind us. Donny had somehow managed to get a full-sized box of Sour Patch Kids, much to our annoyance, and even he didn’t know when or where he got it.
“I’m telling you, I went to all the same houses as you guys!” He said, trying not to laugh, our frustration at how we managed to miss such a prize obvious.
“Bullshit, you’re just gatekeeping it.” I said, digging around to see what I had earned. All of your standard fun-sized candy bars, a few knock-offs mixed in, and one of my unpopular favorites sitting right at the bottom of the bag; a set of gummy vampire teeth. I smiled as I pulled them out, both of my friends wrinkling their noses in disgust.
“I will never understand how you like those fucking things.” Gerald said as he handed me the ones he had gotten, and Donny followed suit.
“I dunno dude, they taste great to me. Like old-ass grandma teeth.” I joked as I clacked my teeth at him, laughing at his unamused expression.
I took one out as Janey walked downstairs, more than likely disturbed from her rest by me and my friends. My little sister was prepared however, and must have already asked her friends before they left if they had any of my favorite candy, and as she walked past me she dropped four more sets of the gummy teeth into my lap.
“There you go, weirdo.” She made a disgusted face at me before turning and marching back upstairs, presumably to bed.
“Love you too, Janey!” I called after her sarcastically, grateful that she took the time to ask her friends. Honestly I was surprised, that was the nicest thing she had done for me since she started middle school earlier this year, besides acknowledging my existence as her older brother, that is. I ripped open one of the packages and took a bite.
A common thing that you will hear or experience is that gummy teeth taste like dirt. Most people hate it, but I loved it. It tasted like nostalgia, old Halloweens, home, etc., so when I bit into the red and white gelatin I froze as I tasted a hint of metal. I pulled away, confused as I looked at the bite marks. Nothing out of the ordinary was there, so I hesitantly took another bite. That same strange metallic tang sat there, alien but not too unpleasant.
“Huh. These… taste a little weird.” I muttered as I swallowed, looking to Donny. He had a stronger stomach between him and Gerald, and figured he’d be more willing to verify my taste buds. He sighed and stuck out his hand, and I placed an unopened set into his hand. He took a single bite and immediately gagged.
“What the hell, what is this?” Donny said as he spat it out. He stared at the packaging and immediately tossed it towards me. “Dude. You need to go throw up.”
“What?” I looked at the packaging, nothing too interesting. It advertised gummy vampire teeth with a cartoon Dracula, made by a vaguely familiar-sounding company called Crazy Delights.
A memory suddenly slammed into my head so hard, I was stunned into silence. Donny had figured it out before me, and was staring at me with concern. I looked up, wide-eyed with shock and complete disbelief. I quickly grabbed the remote, attempting to find the news broadcast from earlier. After a few minutes of what seemed like futile searching I found it and scrolled to the portion of candy recalls, Gerald repeatedly asking what was happening.
“-and finally, the candy company Crazy Delights is issuing a mass recall and warning involving any and all of their gummy-related candies due to foreign contamination from a workplace accident. The details of the accident are unknown at this time, but there is a confirmed death involved. If you already have bought any of their products to hand out to trick-or-treaters, dispose of it immediately. And now, onto the weather for tonight with-”
I didn’t even hear my friends worried reassurances as I stared down at the half-eaten pair of gummy teeth, my stomach doing cartwheels.
My friends left at my request a few minutes later, partly because I didn’t want to worry them, but mostly because I knew I was about to go through the ringer and wanted to spare them from seeing it themselves. I had had bad candy before, and it was not a fun experience, but so far there was nothing. No bubble gut, no nausea, nothing. I gathered my candy off the ground and stopped at my parents room, and seeing them asleep, I quietly placed the Milk Duds I had saved on my father’s dresser with a small smile.
An hour later, and I was still awake, waiting for the hammer of bad choices and stomach problems to slam into me at full force, but there was nothing. If anything I just felt cold and itchy, like someone had been rubbing a frozen sponge over my body. I didn’t have hives, but it was itching bad enough that I was scratching myself raw and red in places, especially my face. My mouth still tasted like the gummy, that nostalgic dirt flavor overridden by the taste of metal.
My stomach began growling, and I remembered there was still a few slices of cold pizza on the stove. I quietly crept downstairs, and froze as I took a step down, hearing a quiet sound echo through the hall, almost sounding like a quiet rip. I took another step and heard the same sound, and looked down to see that my sock had just snagged on a tiny nail head, ripping the heel. I breathed out a sigh of relief as I finished descending, that same rip accompanying every step as my jaw began to feel sore, my teeth aching slightly from the candy I had eaten earlier in the night.
I managed to make it to the kitchen, nearly doubled over with hunger. I was starving, and I grabbed a piece of pizza and took a bite of the cold slice, before whirling to the sink and immediately retching and throwing it back up, panting, tears in my eyes. I coughed and turned on the faucet to rinse out the sink and my mouth and retched again, this time my throat closing like a vice for a split second as I drew my mouth near, the water itself seeming to tremble away from me. I recoiled and stumbled upstairs, my vision blurred from vomiting, but I then smelled something so wonderful, something so sweet and tangy and savory that I needed to see what it was.
I opened my sister’s door quietly, peeking inside to see what she had in her room. Janey was asleep, lying on her side facing the door, and she held her clear candy bag like a pillow in front of her, hugging it close. The scent that came from it was incredible, like nothing I’d ever smelled before, and I crept close, looking through the bag at so many candies and sweets and stuff I had never seen before, all looking like it belonged in a fairy tale. I looked at her sleeping face, and back to the bag. I was so damn hungry, and even though I knew it was my sister’s Halloween prize, I wanted, no, needed it.
I tore open the top of the bag, and it split down the middle as I stuck my hands inside, candy falling out onto the bed and floor. Janey’s eyes shot open, staring at me with half asleep shock for a moment before they fluttered close as her head rested back on the pillow. I grabbed a handful of sweets and popped a few into my mouth, nearly moaning at the intense heavenly taste, like barbecue sauce drizzled over licorice and a touch of that same metallic tang. I was voracious, and I acted as such.
I ate and ate and ate, my hunger bottomless as I shoveled candy into my mouth, my vision blurring to black before coming back in bursts as I feasted, that ambrosia of the gods filling my stomach. I don’t know how long I ate, my jaw hurting from how much I had been chewing, but it wasn’t enough. Her bag had run out of candy, and I was still hungry as I caught scent of more sweets coming from my parents room.
The Milk Duds on the dresser disgusted me, a foul sugary sentry that seemed to judge me as I ate the candy bags that my parents had hidden under their blankets just as delicious as Janey’s, both in their own right. The candy my mother had collected was more sweet, a little sour with citric acid and a hint of what tasted like ketchup or tomato sauce. My father’s had the taste of black licorice and bourbon and chocolate, with a note of something similar to caramel. My mouth was hurting more and more, razor blades dragged across the back of my mouth and jaw as I chewed. I stood as I finished and nearly gagged as I saw the Milk Duds again, and upon realizing that this was going to be more than a mere gag, ran to the bathroom to throw up into the toilet.
I closed my eyes as I threw up, my stomach heaving and my eyes tinged with tears with the effort, before I opened them and stared into the toilet, my eyes widening at the mess.
I stumbled to my feet, recoiling and backing up into the opposite wall, staring at the dark murk in the toilet, I crept back out into the hallway of my unwaking family as I peeked into my sister’s room and saw her laying there, peacefully lying on her deathbed, her stomach and chest unzipped and empty with a crimson mess spreading across the carpet and bed and I stumbled back across the hall and fell into my parents room, turning and feeling my mind begin to slip as I saw my mother with the blood trickling from her mouth as her torso was hollowed in the same fashion, my father similar as well but with his eyes removed, now sloshing around in my stomach as I finally screamed, struggling to my feet as I ran to the bathroom with the crimson chunky mess filling the toilet and finally saw in the mirror why my face had felt itchy and my jaw painful, my skin peeling away in jagged dark red flaps to make room for my jaw, unhinged and held together by bright red tendons as they grew outward to give my jagged teeth room to fit as I screamed and cried and my face felt freezer-burnt as it expanded, splitting and ripping my skin apart in crimson-black gashes across my body that oozed and dripped with my blood as my body grew disproportionately, my scalp shredding to pieces as I felt something stabbing through and growing out while I howled and cried and lost my grip on reality as I smelled more and more candy all around me from all over town, the heavenly scent filling me with nothing but mindless and empty hunger and hunger and hunger aND HUNGER AND