“Regular soda is actually better for you than diet soda”
Both are bad!!! Oh my god!!
Of all the stupid nutrition advice that I see propagated time and again, the idea that regular soda is better for you than diet soda (because chemical=bad?? I guess?) has got to be one of the most idiotic takes that never seems to die.
Without fail, any time I see any kind of “how I eat” content whether from people trying to lose weight or otherwise, if they consume a diet drink, there is ALWAYS some nincompoop being like “uhmm actually diet soda is worse for you.”
I wanna be clear, as initially said, all soda is ultra processed crap that is not healthy for you. Diet soda and artificial sweeteners are unhealthy when consumed in excess. The only foods/drinks that are ultimately healthy are those which are unprocessed or minimally processed.
However, specifically in the context of the average American who, statistically speaking, is overweight or obese, and perhaps no longer wants to be that way, diet soda is 1000% the better option in terms of losing weight.
It boils down to the fact that diet soda contains zero calories, duh, and doesn’t spike your blood sugar. And for the average American possibly grappling with things like insulin resistance and trying to maintain a calorie deficit, that’s important.
Ideally, if someone is trying to get healthier, the best scenario is that they reach a point where they can have a soda on occasion and move on with their life, no big deal.
However, again, the average US adult is overweight/obese, and thus struggles to moderate the consumption of ultra processed beverages and food.
As such, switching out full sugar soda for a diet beverage in the short term while also trying to ween off high-sugar, highly processed food overall is advisable.
Telling obese people online that it is in their interest to drink full sugar, full calorie fucking soda, while they struggle to maintain a calorie deficit, break their addiction to ultra processed food, and face health threats like high blood sugar, is actually despicable.
To the point where it makes me wonder if people are really this ignorant or if they just want to see people fail. Given the absolute shit state of nutrition education in the US and our general food climate, I’m inclined to believe the former is true but who the hell knows.
TL;DR both diet and regular soda are bad for you, one just doesn’t spike your blood sugar or contain calories and that matters a lot for people who are trying to lose weight.
Anyway, if ya’ll have any other examples of equally stupid nutrition advice you often hear from people who have no idea what they’re talking about, lmk I always need a laugh.