Would you take a 70-minute train commute for a 60k raise?

Hi everyone:

I wanted to hear the opinions of people working in the field because, honestly, I'm very confused about this.

I work in accounting, and recently a recruiter contacted me about a senior director role at a fairly well-known and respected company.

The base salary would be about 45k higher, and quarterly bonuses would bring the total increase to around 60k. I'm currently at 110k and have a smaller bonus structure.

I'm 41 years old and have a family of five. I'm also very involved in my kids' activities, practices, games, and all that. So honestly, I'm not sure how to balance it. It's an excellent opportunity, and in reality my current company won't be able to match or even come close to an offer like this in the near future.

The commute would be about 70 minutes by train. I could technically drive, but the train seems like the better and less annoying option.

I'd really appreciate hearing from anyone who has been through a similar decision. Was the salary difference worth the longer commute and the time away from home, or did it wear you down after a while?

Thanks in advance!

reddit.com
u/Longjumping_Egg2701 — 11 hours ago

Does office life gradually make people less emotionally present? Burnout or something different?

I can't tell if this is burnout, age, or just what happens after enough time in corporate environments.

But I've been noticing this same strange thing in a lot of smart people at work, myself included. Especially people who used to be sharp, vocal, full of opinions, and always switched on.

After a few years in office jobs, they become... Smaller in some way. Not exactly quieter socially. That's not the point.

It's more like something inside them becomes quieter.

They don't challenge bad ideas in meetings as much anymore.
They stop having the energy to explain the same point again.
They say "yeah, okay" a lot more than they used to.
It feels like you're watching them ration their emotional battery throughout the day.

The weird thing is that these are often the reliable people and high performers. The people everyone trusts. Not careless or checked-out people.

This hit me recently because I did the same thing. A fellow manager suggested a very weak approach, and I had a whole argument ready in my head. And then I simply... Let it pass. Not because I agreed. I just didn't want to spend the energy.

I don't feel like this is burnout in the classic sense. It feels more like gradually turning into a highly productive background character.

Is this just a natural part of working to live, or do companies unintentionally condition people to become like this? I'm curious to know if other people have noticed this too.

reddit.com
u/Longjumping_Egg2701 — 1 day ago

I Built My Identity Around My Company - What Am I Supposed to Do Now?

I was "the company guy" for almost 18 years. I would tell anyone who would listen how lucky I was, how much I believed in the work, and how much I wanted to help this place grow. I was always saying that this was the best company I could possibly be part of, and that I would probably retire there someday. On top of all that, I was their top performer by a wide margin. Honestly, I thought I had found my home, and that as the company grew, I would grow with it too.

When the pandemic wrecked everything, we came very close to losing the entire business. The company changed direction overnight, and I was working 10 to 14 hours a day, 6 days a week, for close to 14 months off and on, just to try to keep things standing. They thanked me all the time and said more than once that I was a big reason the company survived. They also promised me things. Promotion paths, career goals, a bigger role. None of that happened. Most of it was quietly walked back afterward as if those words had never been said. And of course, none of it was in writing.

The part I still don't know how to deal with is that I basically no longer had a life outside this place. Clients, coworkers, and even people in my personal life know me as "the guy from that company." I let work become such a huge part of who I am that now I don't know how to separate myself from it.

My health has been getting worse for the past few years. In January, I had a serious health incident that put me in the hospital for about 9 days. I think part of me assumed the company would stand by me the way I stood by them when everything was on fire. Instead, I was removed from my role and pushed downward in one way or another, because my health now prevents me from handling a smaller part of the work. I went from being on top, always number 1, to feeling like I was thrown down because of health problems that the work itself helped cause.

So now I'm here, trying to figure out how to work and keep going after feeling like I lost a piece of my identity. I'm trying to keep my head up and make the best of the demotion, but honestly, it's extremely harsh and humiliating. I feel lost, used, deceived, and I don't know what the next step is supposed to be.

I'm trying to remind myself that 18 years of experience, skills, and accomplishments don't disappear just because one company decided to change my role. I'm starting to look at other opportunities now, even though the idea of interviewing again after almost two decades with one company is honestly terrifying. I've been preparing for the interview by reading useful tips from experienced people, and trying to organize my answers so that I feel more confident talking about my experience. Maybe it's time to stop trying to rebuild what I had and start figuring out what comes next.

reddit.com
u/Longjumping_Egg2701 — 7 days ago

I embellished the truth a bit about college, got the job, and now it looks like it's finally going to catch up with me. What should I do?

I've been worried about this since this morning and I can't get it out of my head.

I applied for a job about 12 years ago and eventually got accepted. In the application, I wrote that I was in the process of finishing my community college program, and honestly, that was true at the time. But shortly after that, I failed out, didn't finish, and never went back.

Now, after all these years, I'm doing very well in a field close to tech. I'm not rich or anything, but I make enough money to live on, and I've built a good career here. Recently, they talked about moving me into a better role, but part of the process is that they update my employee profile on their site with the degree I supposedly "earned."

I'm worried that they think I completed it, and I feel sick when I think about it. I'm scared because in my area, finding good tech jobs isn't very easy, and I don't want to destroy my career because of something from years ago. I should be ready for any meetings or discussion, how to do that?

What's the smartest way for me to handle this?

update: I found this subreddit about how to handle difficult meeting and interviews, and it really has countless amazing tips. Do you think they will work out in my case?

reddit.com
u/Longjumping_Egg2701 — 11 days ago

(39M) Is an increase from $35,000 to $45,000 a year worth adding about 45 minutes to my commute?

Right now I drive about 50 minutes to work and 50 minutes back, so I already spend about an hour and 40 minutes in the car every day. I work night shift, and during the school year I usually see my family anywhere from 25 minutes to an hour and 15 minutes a day. Honestly, working nights has really worn me down. My body can't seem to adjust to it.

I was recently offered a job that's sort of a promotion at another company.

My current salary is $118,000. The new salary would be $155,000 before any bonus.

The commute to the new place would add about another 50 minutes total each day, bringing me to around two and a half hours of driving daily.

I know that's a very long time behind the wheel, but with prices the way they are, it's hard not to seriously consider it. The extra money would let me stop stressing over every bill and every grocery run.

Right now things are tight. We're not falling behind, but we're very close to living paycheck to paycheck, and I'm barely able to save anything. Every year I feel like I'm standing still when it comes to retirement. Moving somewhere else isn't an option for us right now. The big positive is that the new job is day shift. So even if I lose more time driving, I'd probably see my family about 3 to 3.75 hours a day instead of barely seeing them while working nights.

At my current job, there also isn't much room for advancement at the moment. The next realistic step would likely be in 14 to 20 months, and that would probably only be an $18,000 to $25,000 increase, though it would also move me to days.

What would you do in this situation? Any advice would be appreciated. Thanks.

reddit.com
u/Longjumping_Egg2701 — 14 days ago

They Just Told Me My Job Is Ending. My Boss Says I Can't Tell People?

Hi everyone. I found out a few days ago that my job is ending, and honestly, it's really affecting me. I work with students as a campus pastor at a faith-based university, so the idea of suddenly having to say goodbye to all of them is very hard. My supervisor told me: "You're not being fired and you're not being laid off, but the role won't exist in the budget for next semester." So... Yeah. I'm basically being laid off.

He also told me that he doesn't want me to tell the students or my colleagues that my position was eliminated, or that I'm leaving because the university won't fund the role anymore. Am I allowed to tell the students that I'm leaving because I have to, not because I chose to?

A lot of the students I work with already have a hard time with the idea of adults disappearing from their lives. Several of them have asked me things like: "You're not going to leave too, right?" And I always responded with something along the lines of: "Only if they make me!" That's why I feel like this matters. I don't want them to think I decided to just move on somewhere else, or that they weren't worth me staying.

I'm not trying to create drama or make the university look bad. I just want to be honest with the students I cared about, especially since trust is such a huge part of my role.

Thanks for reading.

reddit.com
u/Longjumping_Egg2701 — 17 days ago

I Accidentally Found Myself Looking at a $172K Offer... Would I Be Stupid to Turn It Down?

Simply put, the kind of scenario people dream about landed in front of me: I have a job offer that would almost double what I'm making now, and it could genuinely change a lot of things for my family.

For the past 3 weeks, I've been interviewing for a role I had applied to kind of randomly. The funny part is that it wasn't even the same job I applied for - the recruiter talked to me about a higher-level position.

When the conversation got to compensation, I felt like I was pushing it when I gave a range of $122K to $145K per year, since I'm currently at $92K. The recruiter basically told me that $145K was close to the minimum for that level, which honestly threw me off.

That made me feel like maybe I should keep going. But after several interview rounds, it started becoming clearer that this is a serious senior growth/marketing role in an area where most of my experience is either conceptual or comes from being adjacent to it, not from owning it myself.

Somehow, they came back to me with $172K plus relocation help, which means moving my entire family several states away for a job where I'd be expected to build their marketing function. And tbh, I'm not convinced I can do that without falling flat on my face.

My wife thinks I'm selling myself short and says I'll figure it out. But being responsible for things like paid acquisition, lifecycle/email campaigns, technical SEO, analytics, and probably vendor management too, when I haven't worked directly on most of those things, makes me feel like I'd just be waiting for the moment when it becomes obvious I'm not up to it.

At the same time, my current job is calm and relatively comfortable, and I'm hybrid. The new job would be full-time in office, with longer days and much more pressure. The only reason I started casually looking around in the first place is that my company has been doing layoffs and voluntary exits for about 14 months, and things have felt unstable for a while.

Would it be insane to use this offer just to negotiate a raise where I currently am? Or is this one of those moments where you're supposed to take the scary leap because this is money you never imagined you could make? Staying isn't exactly super safe either, but I'm also talking with my current company about moving into another internal role with a decent pay bump, since they suddenly have a lot of gaps they need to fill.

TLDR: Somehow I managed to get myself a $172K offer while I'm currently making $92K. My current company is unstable and doing buyouts/layoffs, but they might move me into a better-paid role. I don't have much hands-on experience for the new job. Should I just take it?

reddit.com
u/Longjumping_Egg2701 — 18 days ago