u/Lopeshine_mockliz

Description:

I know that this theory is already exists and it has even its own page , but here I want to share with some evidence for this theory to defend idea about connection between Puppet and Shadow Freddy.

ShadowCharlie — it is theory that Charlie /puppet kid or/and TCTTC victim is also Shadow Freddy creature. Her soul was split between Puppet and Shadow Freddy.

Side note: this theory doesn’t contradict with CharliePuppet .

Evidence:

(1) Nightmare and Nightmarionne are related, as their original forms, shadow Freddy and Puppet. Nightmare Jumpscare is a different of other Nightmare animatronics.
His Jumpscare is static picture of his face with loud computer noises.
Similar picture we could notice with Nightmarrione, his Jumpscare is also static picture with unknown noises.

(2) Also, another evidence for Nightmare's being the same, is their behaviour:

Both are :

1. <Left door: both stand there and sees similar >

2.<Right door: both stand there and sees similar >

3. <Both shown on the bed , and Nightmare separate his head out of body >

4. <both shown in the Closet >

Are they everywhere or is he everywhere?

(3) ShadowFreddy/ Nightmare/Nightmare ShadowFreddy is Puppet/Nightmarionne
As proven by speculative reasoning about their versions from FNaF 4. It looks very crazy and unclear, but other details also support this for Puppet being related or even same with Shadow Freddy
In the end of TCTTC minigame CakeBear starts to move a bit slowly, when Magenta man already killed The puppet kid, who is confirmed to be puppet by a Puppet's Jumpscare at the end of whole minigame. It can be evidence for Freddy figure being related to Puppet, CakeBear's paranormal activity after murder

(4) The Design Pizza still about giving to children food, it tell us same story as TCTTC, about soul, who became Puppet The building in both minigames has same form
- rectangle, it is the same restaurant.

So TCTTC shows the whole event, while Security Puppet and Design Pizza Show us also Same event , but from two different perspectives.

Design Pizza shows , what was inside building

Security puppet shows, what was outside the building.

And possible Chronology of Charlie’s death:

1. CakeBear/PizzaBear distribute pizza’s to children.

   Later..

2. Charlie got bullied by others and they closed her out of restaurant, security puppet couldn’t to help her and later Magenta man kills her .

Later..

3. Charlie became a spirit, who took PizzaBear form , being the GrayFreddy she is trying to revenge her bullies to stop Pizza distribution.

Later..

4. She finally became Puppet, which is got confirmed by Puppet’s Jumpscare in the ending of TCTTC minigame.

(4) So, now we should to talk about her first form, a spirit, spirit, who was formed out of bear animatronic form, her favourite. Everywhere and anywhere Charlie/Shadow Freddy is only copying form of him, let's compare:

PizzaBear and GrayFreddy are the same form had. Charlie fully copied Freddy.

Classic Freddy and Shadow Freddy also have the same form in every details, except body colour, he copied namely Freddy, because Golden Freddy didn't appeared in Follow me minigame.

Nightmare also is a copy of Nightmare
Fredbear, bear form character

Shadow Freddy's first official appearing was in FNAF2, where he sits in the same pose as Withered Golden Freddy .
He is still coping things.

(5) movement in Save Them and Follow me minigames. Both of them Leads Freddy, but one difference is that in Follow me Shadow Freddy also Leads other classic animatronics, but it is irrelevant.

Freddy is going to Puppet /Shadow
Freddy. Puppet/Shadow
Freddy is leading him. Freddy is still goes.
But Puppet/Shadow
Freddy is still lead him, but where ? What is the end of the both
minigames? Purple guy just broke the Freddy and Puppet/Shadow Freddy is go to unknown place.

same character from these minigames, we can make another step and say :
"Why not for Puppet and Shadow Freddy being the same person?
They plays same role in these games.»
Side note:I know that these places doesn't match with original maps from minigames, I mean, that they behave similar.

(6) ( Lefty argument) special lure machine, named L.E.F.T.E. His design is so familiar, he is bear with bow tie /top / micro, it has the same form and proportions as Rockstar Freddy has . He is copy of him.
Lefty is dark reflection of Rockstar Freddy as Shadow Freddy is just dark reflection of Original Freddy.

Lefty
reflection of
Rockstar Freddy

<They are parallels to them>
GrayFreddy is dark reflection of PizzaBear

They should be related, because connection of two things :

1. they are copies of Freddy

2. they are the same colour ( dark /Gray )

Lefty is also confirmed to be Puppet.

(6) Side note: I don't believe that Classic's are literally Rockstars or RockstarMCI theory, it just one detail:

I think, the relevant of them is Golden Freddy, who is replaced by Lefty , a bear form animatronic, who is referenced to Shadow Freddy by his dark gray colour

In FNaF 2 Dreams cutscenes, puppet Literally replaced the Yellow bear, like her real form, a ghost named Shadow Freddy.

The whole Charlie story is about

One one soul after her death was split es between two spirits, that are based on two things, was nearby to tragedy:

{1} One part of her soul took the Freddy's form and changed it in negative colour of her suffering
. It is Shadow Freddy

{2} The other part of her soul took form of Security
Puppet, the robot, who was too late to save her

And finally, two pieces of her soul gets being putted together in one Body for her , L.E.F.T.E.

WillMan — it is theory, that Bully, who jumpscare the Bite Victim at home from Five Nights at Freddy’s 4 is Actually William Afton and BV‘s father.

In the same time it only based on BVAFTON, but it can works without it, WillMan is combination of Bully2Dad+BVAFTON theories.

Most of this post will be just TwoBullies evidence ( it is just remake of one of my old post ) , because this theory fully supported by TwoBullies .

Evidence:

(1)FoxyBro and FoxyMan sprites are fundamentally different:

1. different skin colour: FoxyBro's skin colour is darker than FoxyMan has

2. different hair colour: FoxyBro has black hair, but FoxyMan has no hair

3. different mask colour: FoxyBro's mask is brighter

4. different ears form (on the mask)

5. different eyes: FoxyBro's mask has pupils, while FoxyMan has no pupils, his eyes are empty

6. jaws: FoxyMan's mask has teeth in down jaw

7. FoxyBro‘s shirt is without sleeves, while FoxyMan‘s has sleeves.

(2) FoxyMan‘s look not only different, it looks older , he looks older . FoxyMan‘s mask is similar to withered Foxy:

It looks creepy ( Withered animatronics are frankly creepy) . It has similar form to Foxy mask in GGGL minigame , where we could see UnWithered animatronics mask ,why?

Because Freddy’s mask colour is the same as CakeBear from TCTTC. CakeBear is UnWithered Freddy, because Button says about it, so then FoxyMan being older than FoxyBro, wearing the older version of Foxy mask .

(3) FoxyMan‘s identity can be solved, using FNAF 3 minigames Follow Me , where we could see a Purple guy, who became Springtrap. He is definitely William Afton , but look at his poses , when he got scared :

First pose

1. Same slopped neck

2. both hand are pulled forward

3. both have dense body

Second pose

1. same Slooped neck

2. both pull their right hand
   is up

3. both pull forward their second hand

4. both have dense body

Same poses, different mood, being FoxyMan William trying to scare BV, while being Purple guy in FNAF he is scared of souls

(4) Another important detail is slooped neck, it is true pattern for purple guy's appearance, if we could to see the Purple guy in Save Them minigames or in tutorialUnit in FFPS cutscenes
Another connection:

Purple guy ( FNAF 2) has slooped neck

Purple guy (FNAF 3) has slooped neck

FoxyMan ( FNAF 4) has slooped neck

TutorialUnit (FNAF:FFPS) has slooped neck

Coincidence?

(5) Also another evidence for William has connection to Foxy is his appearance in Foxy Go Go Go minigame, when Foxy goes from pirate cove, William gets smile, like it is his favourite animatronic ,as SpringBonnie.

MikeGarrett— it is Theory that Garrett Schmidt from Five Nights At Freddy’s movie became Michael Afton from Five Nights At Freddy’s movie 2 .

Side note: I don’t believe it, it is just reasoning , but I also admit , that other people could came think to this .

Evidence:

1. in Mike Schmidt’s memories we have never seen like Garrett died , Mike saw only kidnapping of his brother, but not death . Maybe it wasn’t even murder , because there’s no animatronics( except Circus Baby ) , which William could stuff him .

So Willam’s motivation is unclear, probably he didn’t kill Garrett, he had a different goal.

2. under MoviesClues , some things from games are related to movies :

For example: in FNaF:SL Michael Afton watched the Immortal and Restless soap opera, where main characters are Vampire Vlad and woman Clara , who are representation of Afton parents ( under TIATRAftons theory) .

Vlad often says interesting phrase :

“The baby isn’t mine”

In the context of lore we could ask : what if Michael actually isn’t William’s son , just adopted or kidnapped person , who is similar to him, also in Movies .

( i understand, that Movie are different universe

Movies are Movies

Games are Games )

3. William could brainwashed Garrett to think , that he is his son out of cruelty. William good manipulate people, so he could do that.

4. on one of family photos of Afton Family , Vanessa’s brother shown as her younger brother, it good matches with Garrett .

Also under GarrettBV : Garrett has connection to BV as character.

But Vanessa’s brother also similar to BV:

1. Both wore striped shirts

2. Both are younger brother

3. Both have similar hair style

About hair style :

It isn’t Far-Fetched , because Michael’s hair style is similar to Michael’s hair style from cutscenes in FNaF:SL custom nights, but in movies his hair are darker .

Problem:

1)Garrett’s age is too small for Vanessa’s brother.

2)Garrett had brown eyes , but Michael has blue eyes .

• William could made him in robot body .

PlushHenry theory— it is theory that Henry Emily is the voice behind the plush Fredbear toy from FNaF 4’s minigames .

Evidence:

1. Henry has connection to Fredbear character.

In novels Henry wore the Fredbear springlock suit.

In games we have some similar situation , under HenryFredbear theory he also probably wore this suit .

Side note : it can works with idea that , Fredbear performer could be different person , so it wouldn’t contradict with PlushHenry theory, because Henry still could speak through this toy.

2. CassetteMan and PlushBear also have connection:

Both are Leads the protagonist of the game :

1. Plushbear warns BV ( FNaF 4 minigames protagonist ) out of danger , saying :

„Hurry and leave „

2. CassetteMan leads the Franchisee( probably one of FFPS protagonists ) how to salvage and check the animatronics .

In the same time protagonists of both games are similar( Franchisee literally represent as pale/yellow bear ) and ( BV has connection to Plusbear/Freddy/Funtime Freddy ) ,

Then why not for voices from cassettes and Plushbear being the same .

3. Plushbear also says the phrase:

„Do you remember what you saw ? „

He said that , when BV way close to Fredbear suit performer , likely that Henry know what happened in FFD , if he is one of founders, so he could referenced to BV‘s fear .

4. Under BVEmily + SammyVictim , Henry had motivation to create a toy for following to his own Child, Sammy, at least, when worked .

FoxyBroMM - it is theory that Midnight Motorists mini game protagonist ( Mustard Man) actually is BV's Older brother from Five Nights at Freddy's

Side note: this theory good works with BVAfton, but can work without it.

Evidence:

Hand unit and phone guy are related because:

1. HandUnit is literally another version of phone guy, which words were the most source of info about place where we are

2. some their words aren't true

Phone guy said that animatronics sees other people as endo's and according to program they must put endo in suit, if they see you then they put the player in suit, but it isn't true. When we see Bonnie in parts of service, he doesn't make anything with Endo01.

HandUnit like phone guy ignores the danger, also he says things, that leads to getting jumpscare, opposite Circus Baby who say really good tips

3. if we invert their colours, then we get almost identical designs, that changed according to circuit:

1. Blue -> Orange

2.0range-> Blue

Also, inverted HandUnit has connection to phone toy from Fnaf 4 main gameplay location:

1)both are blue colour

2. Phone toy has connection to phone guy, HandUnit also has connection to phone guy

3. Both has eyes and cartoon look

4. both have pink eyes

So, which identity chain we have after analysis for

nOw:

1. Phone guy is related to HandUnit

2. HandUnit is related to phone toy

3. phone toy is related to phone guy

Phone guy also has connection to Foxy animatronic, not being possessed animatronic (normal human) he should be older brother which one peculiarity is love to Foxy

What Phone guy says?

"Foxy was always my favourite"

And Mustard Man with FoxyBro have connection:

1. both are associated with

HandUnit

2. both have similar body structure

3. both are so cruel:

1. FoxyBro tortured his younger brother until he died

2. Mustard Man screams on his child and ignores CouchPerson word's, also he is drinked and he has problem with alcohol

4. both have their own child, who is male:

1. Mustard Man has the child, who escaped/ or was kidnapped through the window

2. FoxyBro ( under PlushKidNephew theory)

probably also has a son, who is speculating male (under PlushKidBoy theory)