Laughing in the Dark Podcast Insight on An Episode
If you haven't checked it out yet, there's a relatively new Are You Afraid of the Dark? podcast called Laughing in the Dark, hosted by four Gen X/older Millennial fans. I've really warmed up to it.
Their latest episode covers The Tale of Old Man Corcoran, one of my favorite episodes from Season 2, and they offered an interpretation I hadn't heard before. They suggest that Kiki's story is her way of processing what it feels like to be the only Black member of the Midnight Society.
The episode centers on two Black boys who move into a new neighborhood and try to fit in with a group of mostly white kids. The group's leader welcomes them, but the others seem reluctant to let them join. I'd always read those scenes as the kids subtly trying to warn the newcomers away from Marshall, but the podcast made me reconsider whether it's significant that the outsiders trying to assimilate are Black.
It also made me rethink Kiki as a character. She's often labeled as having a bad attitude, but maybe some of that comes from feeling like an outsider in a predominantly white group—a feeling a lot of us who grew up in those spaces can relate to. Whether or not that was the writers' intent, I thought it was a thoughtful reading of the episode.
The hosts have had other interesting takes, too. One of their running jokes is that Betty Ann "hates immigrants" because two of her stories involve suspicion toward Eastern Europeans and aliens. On a more serious note, they argue that The Tale of the Final Wish works as an allegory for abuse, and they were quick to point out just how terrible the adults are in The Tale of the Shiny Red Bicycle.
If you're looking for an AYAOTD podcast that goes beyond plot recaps and offers thoughtful discussion, I'd definitely recommend giving Laughing in the Dark a listen.