A serious discussion about why maybe certain forbidden (or otherwise) acts are not fully explained.
Disclaimer: This topic will discuss topics like sex and the like. If you feel uncomfortable, please leave. If you just want a Tldr, see the last conclusion section. I will lay my thinking process and finalize with the question.
Opener: I am a firm believer in my religion and found it was tailored for the human psyche. Your faith is yours alone and your prayers are a reflection of your deepest desires, after all nobody would still lie when a genie comes out of the bottle. It helps us reorganize our thoughts and priorities, and throughout the journey, it teaches us to be grateful for what we have and what we get. You can only wish for what you do not have to begin with, and that you wish stays the same, and that teaches us humility.
Point 1: As such, my understanding of Islam is, it's God's guidance for the individual and their community. We do not bet to help people not pick up the habit of gambling. Not to drink to be protected from addiction and so forth. All standard ideas.
Question 1: That is where a certain question arises. Things that are forbidden like drinking, eating pork and sleeping around, although are not explicitly stated in their severity on a clear scale, unlike Kufr for instance, I believe they are not all equal. Killing in vain is not the same as knowingly eating pork for example. One harms others and is disruptive to society, which is common sense, while the second we are not clearly told. Could be our favorite excuse of the evil worm in its meat, or could be any other reason. We are not explicitly told why, and we are not told if there are exceptions (outside of necessity).
This raises a certain line of thinking. Why are we not told why certain things are forbidden? I am not asking for some abstract answer like, "God knows best" - we aren't in the 50's anymore, such answers do not convince or hold meaning nowadays. I am looking at the topic from a more philosophical perspective, or a psychological one even. Main reason I am posting this on a progressive sub to begin with.
We can guess the reasons, we can go back to Hadith (Which are not usually credible), but in reality, our framework - the basis of our religion, the Quran, omits the reasons almost as if provocatively, or at least I thought so before. "What will you do about being told not to do something you don't understand? Can't have sex or drink, sure you can guess why, but why not pork? You can't know why and it's to test your faith. Is it because it's unclean? Something you haven't learned about yet? How about other, cleaner pig species? How about lab grown pig meat?" - sort of thing.
Point 2: But lately I have been looking at it from a different perspective. As I said at the start, it's a religion tailored for us, for our way of thinking and for human nature. Fundamentally, how can I hold the belief that the religion is meant to stay the same for thousands of years, that seems faulty right? Times change, and so do people - how come Allah would create a religion that refuses a fundamental aspect of life - change? Not as in picking what I want to follow and disregarding the rest or saying "ok well I'm a good person and Allah will surely not judge me harshly" - not that sort of change I am alluding to.
I am beginning to question if the things that are forbidden are left purposefully open ended so that they can be overridden when appropriate.
As in, it prompts learning first and foremost, like the rest of the religion does. Think about it. The Quran for example is not explained to us so we can read it, understanding it and learn from studying it. Perhaps the idea of certain things being forbidden should also be studied and are left to the person to make the final decision.
You must first learn and seek the knowledge behind why they are forbidden, and depending on your circumstances, decide whether or not it applies to you while still being a full fledged Muslim. While I realize the paradox of what I just said, "how can you deny the very thing you claim to believe in", but my point is, I am not denying Islam's teachings - I am saying our understanding of what haram entails might have been overly aggressive, something that is not foreign to the Islam community and our cultures throughout the hundreds of years. Most of our understandings are born out of uneducated guesses made by people long gone.
Like recently when I studied and looked more into marriage, many of our marriage problems arise from cultural norms and traditions, not what the Quran said. Two adults can just proclaim their marriage and agree on the terms of their marriages, within reason, and tada - they are married. You don't need a Sheikh or anything of the sort - they are all just customs.
Point 3: That raises a supporting argument. Just because it is not explicitly told in the Quran that I can override something that I am forbidden from doing, does not mean doing what the Quran says is always right. Not in an explicit sense of course, but take Mutaha marriage or whatever it is called as an example where they get married for a short time just for sex. Even though it can follow the Quranic rules exactly, is it actually Halal to find a loophole? Assuming they follow all the rules and let "people" (friends, her pimp or whatever) know. Now, I can't claim for certain because God stands in judgement for both cases, not me, but its point is to illustrate that the Quran is left open ended because not only times and people change, but because we can expand on it depending on the situation.
Conclusion: That brings me back to my first point now that I have laid down my logic. Is it possible that we are not explicitly told why some things are forbidden so that we study them, and through studying them we realize their risks and then it is up to us to contain said risks? Allah would not care who we sleep with, or if we drink and eat pork. Those are rules for us, but by understanding them, we can better our judgement.
As in, when as a kid you are told not to eat an entire chocolate cake, that does not mean it's a rule for the rest of your life. It is a rule until you mature [understand the religion and why certain things are forbidden] that you can then override.
And like when your father said 60 years ago, "Don't invest in real estate" - That does not mean he will be raised from the dead when you do and proclaim his disappointment in you. It just means it might not have been a suitable business plan back then or did not seem worth it.
Anyway, would love to hear your thoughts. Challenge them if you wish or agree, but please remember that it is easy to write a comment, but it is never easy to understand years of thinking through a glance, form an opinion and post it in the span of a couple of minutes. Take your time if you wish.