
Conspiracy & Sushi - Where testimonies can take you
When I was 11, we were living in Japan on Misawa Air Base. A local Japanese family wanted me to come stay the weekend with them.
I was super excited about it. I packed all my things, they pull up in front of our house. I say bye to my family and hop in their car.
As we start driving away, I remembered that I am a really picky eater. They probably were going to want me to eat sushi.
The cold grip of utter fear squeezes my little stomach.
This was the most dangerous situation I’ve ever been in as kid.
So what does a little Mormon boy do? He prays.
I prayed hard.
The hardest anyone has ever prayed.
No man has ever come close.
Not even 14 year old Joseph in the Sacred Grove.
“Heavenly Father! Please! I need your help! If you really love me, you will spare me! I promise I’ll be good! I can’t eat Sushi!”
Just as I was praying my heart out, the mother turns to me and asks, “Do you like McDonald’s?”
“YES!”
“Well we can go have McDonald’s for dinner, then we’ll go to the grocery store and you can pick anything you’d like to eat for the weekend.”
THANK YOU, GOD!
I KNEW YOU WERE REAL!
YOU REALLY DO LOVE ME!
These were exactly the kind of experiences you shared in church and especially in testimony meetings.
A testimony meeting happens once a month, usually on the first Sunday. People fast and pray and then rather than having assigned speakers, it’s an open mic night.
Anyone from the congregation can get up and bear their testimony in front of everyone.
Little kids are always encouraged to go on up and say things like, “I know Heavenwy Fatha wuvs me. I wuv my famiwee. In da name of Jeesas Cwyst, Amen!” (Typing that out, sounded more like Elmer Fudd, but you get what I was going for.)
A lot of people share their miracles and blessings. So many stories about lost keys, purses and wallets being found as soon as they prayed for help.
I told that McDonald’s story in testimony meetings and used it on my mission. I wasn’t faking it. Everyone laughs.
The more extreme certainty I used, the more people loved it.
I could feel it.
In every other area of life, being completely certain about something you have zero evidence for is a red flag.
People organize interventions for that.
But in church we call it a testimony and shove a microphone in your face.
This trained me to notice coincidences every day of my life and frame them as revelation or lessons from God.
So if the average human lives for 30,000 days.
And something has a 1/1000 chance of happening, throughout your life you’ll experience it around 30 times.
Now add in everything else with better odds and your list starts growing fast.
I claimed some coincidences as messages from God.
My brother claims all coincidences as messages from God.
And that gap, makes all the difference.
There are never any coincidences in his life. God is always sending him messages.
“I was thinking of a song and when I walked into the store, they were playing it on the speakers! God was telling me that he knows what I’m thinking!”
He uses the same logic and pattern-matching to also believe in flat earth, lizard people, aliens, any conspiracy you can probably think of. He’s on board.
It makes sense though, if God is always sending him messages, then God is probably controlling his social media feed. So there is a reason Nazis keep showing up while he scrolls TikTok.
Once he started sharing his antisemitic views is when the rest of my family realized this was becoming a serious issue.
“How can he believe this stuff?!”
“It’s so obvious none of THAT is real!”
We tried talking to him, but we couldn’t convince him that these things weren’t true.
I started showing him videos debunking flat earth and how the holocaust was real.
Nothing works.
Why can’t he see the logic? Not every coincidence means something!
It’s not like he grew up in an organization that incentivized him into thinking that every little thing has a deeper meaning behind it… right?
Who has the right to tell him that these Instagram Reels aren’t being put in front of him as special things God needs him to know?
He has told me, “I think the prophets and apostles know this stuff is true. But most members aren’t ready to accept it yet.”
The church can’t fix this.
This isn’t just a side effect, this is the main effect. The church expects that we’ll have our own intellectual guardrails.
But in a radical religious person’s eyes, they think moderates aren’t taking religion seriously enough.
How can a bishop tell a member they can’t receive direct revelation from God through their microwave?
“The Lord only communicates through church approved appliances.”
There is absolutely no way the church can tell someone how to receive and interpret their own personal revelations.
As long as you got SOME kind of revelation pointing you to the church doors, then that works!
The problem is that still leaves plenty of room for people to become extreme conspiracy theorists.
What the church hopes they learn, is how to be more tactful with revelations.
If our microwave member instead phrases their revelation as, “When heating up my chicken, this reminded me that the Lord does similar things to make us feel a burning in our bosom.”
That’s the kind of metaphor you hear from the highest ranking members of the church.
But it’s still just as crazy.
You can’t expect people to question their conspiracy beliefs without also questioning their church beliefs.
It’s all tied together for them.
Plus, how much weirder is it to get revelation from a microwave than a rock inside a hat?
The only real way out is to question your beliefs. To leave room for pure coincidence. To learn how probability actually works.
Those aren’t things the church can hand members struggling with extreme beliefs.
Because those methods don’t stop at flat earth, aliens, and antisemitism.
They come for everything.
They teach you how to think critically about what you believe.
Once you pull that thread, you can’t control where it goes.
I pulled it.
It can be very destabilizing.
But every tug is worth it.
And today, I actually love sushi.
TL;DR
When I was a kid I prayed harder than any human in history to avoid eating sushi while staying with a Japanese family. God answered my prayer when the family took me out to McDonald's.
I was trained by the church that every coincidence was actually revelation and blessings from god. When you bare testimony about these coincidences people respond more positively when you sound more certain, and that reinforces this behavior.
When something has a 1/1,000 chance of happening once a day of your life, you can have that happen 30 different times over the average lifespan. Crazy coincidences are actually pretty common.
My brother was raised in the same environment and he views every coincidence as a message from god. He also now believes Flat Earth, Lizard People, and now antisemitic content in his social media feeds.
I've heard my brother say he thinks the prophets and apostles know these conspiracies are true, but the Mormons aren't ready to hear it yet.
The church can't help people like him because the same critical thinking skills needed to disbelieve these conspiracy theories are the same ones that threaten the church's authority.