MBA goal refinement: Energy Strategy Consulting vs Oil Major Strategy + how recruiting really works?
Hi everyone,
I’m currently preparing for MBA applications (targeting top schools like INSEAD / LBS / HEC) and trying to finalise my post-MBA goal. I’d really appreciate insights from people who have been through consulting or energy recruiting.
My background:
- Process Engineer with ~5 years experience in LNG / large EPC projects
- Currently exploring MBA as a pivot into strategy roles in the energy sector
- Long-term goal: build and scale my family business into an energy transition solutions provider
At this stage, I’m refining between two post-MBA paths:
1) Energy Strategy Consulting (Kearney, EY-Parthenon, Strategy&, Roland Berger, Oliver Wyman)
vs
2) Strategy role at Oil & Gas majors (Shell, BP, TotalEnergies, etc.)
I’m trying to understand:
- What is the real difference in day-to-day work between these two roles post-MBA?
- Which role gives better exposure to energy transition, capital allocation, and strategic decision-making?
- For someone aiming to eventually build a business in energy transition, which path is more valuable long-term?
MBA recruiting questions:
I also wanted to understand from a recruitment perspective:
- At top MBA programs, what do Energy Strategy Consulting firms actually look for in candidates?
- Is prior technical / engineering experience in energy seen as an advantage, or do they primarily prefer generalist consulting profiles?
- How structured is recruiting for energy consulting vs oil major strategy roles during MBA (timelines, competitiveness, interview style)?
Application question:
Finally, for people who have applied to top B-schools:
- If someone comes from a technical energy background, do admissions committees actually value a post-MBA goal of moving into Energy Strategy Consulting?
- Or do they prefer more “traditional consulting / finance” narratives during application and interviews?
Would really appreciate any real-world insights, especially from people who have worked in either of these paths or gone through MBA recruiting recently.
Thanks in advance!