Review for the Earl of Dracumont by B.H Crogen - cannot decide if its amazing or very bad
Yo, after my last negetive review went without a hitch I have finally finished a book I didnt 100% love so why not make another. Ngl this review came out longer then I expected.
The harem book follows El - a boy with Noble (magic) Blood who gets fucked over as a child, loses EVERYTHING and is thrown into the shittest jail for 15 years. Too bad he manages to escape and is now looking for REVENGE. The story is set in a medival fantasy world which is honestly not super original but good enough. Overall I would say the plot and worldbuilding is fine: nothing u have never seen before but still good.
So why such a title? I shall list the positives and negetives and ull understand.
Postives: first, unlike most op mcs, we actually get to experience alongside the MC all the garbage he suffers in first 30% of the book. What that means is by the end of it when he becomes an OP 2 meters tall alpha chad i cheer him on as he gets the ladies and moves up in the world instead of rolling my eyes.
Second, the MC actually earns all his chad powers: he trains for a DECADE before becoming a chad.
Third, MC has REAL male friends. Yes, that is rare enough to count as a postive.
Fourth, the MC has REAL character development and is overall very well written.
And now we move on to the negetives: first, remember how good the MC is? Too bad the rest of the characters are... fine? They arent badly written but experience no character growth at all. The supportive characters orbit around the MC and thats about it.
Second, the villans are also.. meh. U HATE them because of the shit they did to MC but they are not intresting as characters either.
Third and worst of them all: maybe its a pet peeve, but the author overuses.. not sure how to call it? Dramatic language? And it becomes overlly grating. Like 30% of the book is written like (the next statements are edited to avoid spoilerd):
"A and B rose together and cleared the table without being asked, moving in the quiet coordination of two people who had settled into a shared rhythm. The household had learned early on the ship that clearing your own plate was not welcome. Both servants had made that boundary clear, and no one had tested it since". Or "MC stood alone in the entry hall. In his hand, the contract of a woman who didn't yet know her life had changed. In his pocket, a ring that didn't fit his hand. In his pack, over thirteen hundred gold pieces and a bruise on his left arm that would fade by morning. Everything he had set in motion since walking into this city was falling into place. The plan taking shape around him. C sworn. B loyal. D incoming. And now this. The final piece, held in his hand like a key to a door he had been standing in front of since the first time she hid behind her hair and called him boss".
Do u see what I mean now? Dont get me wrong writing this way is sometimes usefull: looking back at the achievements MC has gotten or marking an importent moment. But its so over used in the book it drove me nearly crazy.
So.. yeah. Overall Im giving it a 5/10 - the postives want a 8/10 and the negetives 3/10 and that is the compromise.