u/MoreDistribution4696

I am going through older observations of a bird. Like even years back. The observations are correct but it’s only the original poster and nobody else has agreed. Is it useful or even make a difference to press agree on these? Based on how long it’s been

Edit: Thank you everyone for the advice. I’m glad I can make a difference. BTW I am referring to cases where nobody has agreed whatsoever yet

I’m trying to fill in the gaps of info my grandfather has been telling me. If anyone has any information, especially academic resources, I would love to read. Thank you. And as a bonus if you have any papers/books on rural Northern China as a whole and its history I am open to those too.

By retribution, I mean revenge, or ways of revenge. Whether legal, personal, criminal, etc.

I am asking in context of rural China, where people often had to go on living together (and for generations afterwards).

In Northern China it appears this might’ve been more bearable because less violence. But Guangxi and other places seem difficult given the amount of killing in villages.

So my question is, how did people seek retribution? Or was there any? I would be curious to know & even get recommendations for books/papers to read on the subject.

Thank you.

Edit: At this point I just want some academic sources & info if possible. Not really interested in debating anything. If it helps, my own family is from rural Northern China. My grandfather was a “red guard” which seems deviated from the city definition, as he was in his 30s. The stories are interesting but very different from city literature hence why I need rural resources. And the dynamics such as pinzhongxianong which were NOT in the city. Families and last name lineages also impacted everything.

I found Su Yang’s book which discusses Guangxi & Guangdong. I would love to read books from various rural areas in China. Thank you.