u/Obvious-Pick5496

I really liked “Aquarian Gaze” from the Pacifica brand. However, I think it has been discontinued as I have not been able to find it locally or online. I’ve tried many other formulas and I always get black smudge transfers on my under eye after a couple hours of wear. I do get my upper lashes done with extensions but my lower lashes are too light that it looks as unbalanced without mascara. I think my issue is the other ones I’ve tried are not “waterproof.”

Other mascaras I have tried:
Pacifica: Dream Big
Pacifica: Stellar Gaze
Pacifica: Surf Lash
Covergirl: Lash burst Cleantopia