Build up retirement vs eliminate debt? Which to prioritize
Good morning.
So some quick background - I'm turning 40 in a couple months. I completed my PhD a few years ago, and have just been offered a job in Washington (state) with a salary of $205k.
I've got DEBT, and I also don't really have any meaningful retirement saving - my 401k is currently sitting at about $13k. I have a car loan ($~20k at 10.5%ish), a debt consolidation loan that I used to payoff my credit cards (~$33k @ ~8%), private student loans (~$7.5k @ ~ 6.5%), and public student loans (about $190k @ ~ 6.5%). On the plus side, I've somehow managed to deal with all that - and my mortgage, and my credit score is above 800.
With this new role, I'm looking at some degree of financial security for the first time in my life, which is pretty exciting. We are looking to sell our current home in Oregon and buy a house in WA, and we're targetting around $750k and monthly payments in $5-6k range. There might be cheaper options, like renting, but home ownership is personally important to us, so is a priority.
So, that's the brief financial picture. We live pretty non-extravagant lives, so after mortgage payment and making at least minimum payments and other bills, I'm looking at around 3-4k/month that I'll have "left over", and I'm trying to decide what to target that money towards. Obviously I'm going to max employer match on 401k, but I'm still gonna have several thousand per month "left over".
One option is to aggressively pay off loans, with the goal of having a better DTI to buy a "forever home" in ~5ish years. in 5ish years, the debt consolidation and car loans will be gone with minimum payments (already accounted for in budget), and I could put a big dent in the $190k public student loans or depending on how things shake out, maybe get out from under it entirely in that period. That would obviously be good if we're looking to stretch our budget to get a "forever home" around that period.
Another option would be to make minimum payments on the loans - which would still pay off the car and debt consolidation loan - but probably wouldn't have a meaningful impact on the big student loan balance, but focus the "extra money" on ensuring I'm hitting annual 401k contribution limits to try and "catch up" after not really having anything put aside for retirement up until this point. That's attractive because, yknow, interest. Any funds leftover after maxing out 401k contributions could then go towards debt service, but again, not likely to meaningfully impact that big debt.
Are there other options I should consider? Out of the two options I listed, are there pros/cons to each I might want to consider?