Considering bailing out on the crate training for 11 week old puppy
Background:
My 5 year old bernedoodle loved his crate and it helped dramatically with the potty training. Now he's 80 pounds and rarely goes in his crate but will if told to. The crate was helpful in calming him and keeping hims safe.
Now we have a new bernedoodle, 11 weeks old today, and he's expected to be about 90 pounds. I've been introducing him to our crate (with a divider to make it small again) and puppy likes it but when locked in there, he's miserable. He loves eating in there, hanging out, but if the door is shut he's unhappy.
Meanwhile, we puppy proofed a room in our house (pretty well, there's basically nothing for him to get hurt by) and moved him in there. It's been about 4 nights. He's sleeping under the bed very nicely We leave the door ajar to the dog run where there's a small area he can access and he's had ZERO accidents while he's in that room. He wakes up during the night, and I take out out there and he poops like clockwork. This morning I woke up and found a poop out there which must have happened while I was asleep, and that's the second time he's gone on his own.
When he takes a nap then goes potty, he gets rewarded by getting to run around in our main house where there is lots going on - another dog, kids, tons of stuff to check out.
Yesterday there was a party here and he was out the mingling and he had an accident - but our house is big and he was SO far from the potty area I think he forgot :)
But, I am kinda starting to feel like his potty training is going very nicely even though he doesn't sleep in the crate AND he seems to love the quiet bedroom as his home and naps often in there AND he just seems happy and calm since we stop trying to get him into the crate.
So I'm thinking about abandoning the crate. I also am thinking that our adult dog hasn't needed his crate in years and he's so big that in an emergency or vet visit he's just on a leash anyways - and the new dog will be bigger.
But, I worry that abandoning the crate might be mistake. It's the technique I know and trust. Any input much appreciated.