Would Jeremiah Smith be the least controversial non-QB/RB Heisman pick in history?
Clearly the best player in the country and on record-setting statistical pace this season. There's people who at the time in '97 thought Peyton Manning should've won. DaVonte Smith won when others were backing his teammate Najee Harris (even though he wasn't even a finalist) or Trevor Lawrence and it also occurred in a shortened COVID season. Travis Hunter had people believing Ashton Jeanty should've won.
I'm not old enough to have experienced the discourse of Tim Brown in '87 or Desmond Howard in '91.