I think Townfall will be a cult classic
It may not be popular now, but I feel like it will gradually be adored as time goes on.
Personally, I understand the criticisms surrounding the stealth mechanics. If the game was going to force us into a particular playing style, it should have made it far smoother and satisfying.
Than I thought about it for a bit; this isnt metal gear or splinter cell, the stealth mechanics were never going to be perfect. Because they weren't meant to be. Most of the anxiety and dread would immediately disappear if you were able to explore your surroundings like a ninja blending into the shadows. The jank IS the experience.
Leople seem to forget that Silent Hill 2 wasnt universally loved. GameSpot gave it a 7.7 and many reviewers disliked the camera and combat. Now, it's considered one of the best games ever made.
Most of the issues people have with this game can be fixed with patches, i wouldn't change anything with the story or the major areas. Some fine tuning of certain aspects could go a long way with pleasing the crowd, but I feel like it would be a mistake long-term, allowing people to blast through would take away much of the anxiety inducing experience. Let people get frustrated as they learn how to play the game.
Story was fairly unique compared to other silent hills. it does fall into the same tropes as most of the silent hill games. However, It does enough to differentiate itself that I do feel like it will be constantly revisited as time goes on. People will start figuring out the game and share their guides and tips online, which would make the game more and more accessible.
Overall, this game gets unnecessary hate and im pretty disappointed with its sales performance. Compared to f, I think Konami will interpret this as people being more receptive to more action oriented games rather than survival horror, which is a real shame.
originally posted on r/silenthill but got removed for some reason