
This or That Tuesday
It's time for This or That Tuesday. I will show you two or more cards with similar effects and power level and you tell me which one you'd pick if all of them were in a pack and/or which one you'd run in a typical old border cube. I try to avoid cards that need strong synergies to be good since you don't get any context in form of a specific cube, but for the sake of this thread just assume you have a typical old border cube that runs all of the best pre-Mirrodin old border cards, but no overpowered retro frame cards.
Today we'll talk two colorless mass removal cards - Powder Keg and Nevinyrral's Disk. While they don't really do exactly the same I believe their effects are close enough to each other to compare them and pick a favourite. Powder Keg is cheaper, can be nightmare for token decks and you can make it one-sided more easily, but Nevinyrral's Disk resets the board completely for a very reasonable cost if it doesn't get removed before you can untap with it. Which one do you pick more often or which one is your personal favourite?
Bonus question: What is your favourite mass removal spell?