I think I have finally solved the ChatGPT astrology problem
▲ 65 r/beginnerastrology+2 crossposts

I think I have finally solved the ChatGPT astrology problem

I have been very vocal about my frustration with doing Astrology on Claude and ChatGPT here and here..

You see i tried -

  1. viral astrology prompts (give birth details and it will do forecasts)
  2. copy pasting the data everytime
  3. attaching the kundali pdf
  4. attaching screenshots.

The problem is that ChatGPT and Claude are language models, not astrology engines. They will makes mistakes in generating Kundali

So I did something different..

Instead of asking AI to generate a Kundali, I created a downloadable Markdown Kundali file containing the important kundali details. The Kundali data is comparable to any benchmarked astrology software.

Now I simply attach that file and start chatting with the AI. Always works perfectly!

Now I dont say that this should be used for making predictions.. but a lot of people use it for their emotional needs and thats where it can help.

If anyone wants to try it out.. here's the link. I would love to get your thoughts and feedbacks on this

u/Physical_Author_3887 — 11 days ago
▲ 28 r/Nakshatras+1 crossposts

Why you should not use ChatGPT for Astrology - 3 Reasons

I recently asked everyone on Nakshatra subreddit regarding their viewpoint of AI for astrology and there was a common concensus -

Use ChatGPT only for learning purposes.. do not rely for predictions.

However! I have seen A LOT of people use Chatgpt for astrology. So, before going to the next chat, here a few things to keep a few things in mind. (from a guy who is into Astrology and AI)

First… kundali accuracy.

You cannot simply enter birth details and expect perfect chart generation, unless you use a high reasoning model that creates custom script in Python language to generate your kundali. This exhausts a lot of tokens and it still doesn’t calculate a lot of important things such as the shadbala and bhav bal.

Second… hallucination.

Even if you upload a kundali screenshot, these systems often misread placements and confidently give wrong interpretations.

Remember, General LLMs are intelligent liars! :)

Third… prediction depth.

Serious predictions require layered analysis across D1 charts, D9 charts, dasha periods, transits and the relevant divisional charts.

General AI systems are simply not built for that.

Now coming to the biggest issue: while talking to ChatGPT, you know it's limitation but there are AI Astrologers marked as real astrologers!! This has become a trend and this is where you need to be very careful.

If you are going to take a consultation, from ChatGPT, AI astrologers or human astrologers, you should keep in mind a few things so that you are making an informed decision. I have listed these things here.

u/Physical_Author_3887 — 1 month ago

AI Astrologer.. Is it good or bad? Need your honest opinion

People are going crazy about AI.. for astrology.

ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini - people are asking them everything. Kundali generation, compatibility, life predictions. And honestly, AI influencers have made this 10x worse by hyping it without any caveats.

There's nothing wrong with that, but what worries me is awareness around using AI for Astrology and in what limits?

For example,

If you give them your birth details and ask to create the kundali.. Most LLMs make incorrect kundali

They can't do proper prediction. (They are good storytellers and can tell about patterns, but not predictions)

Not just this.. there are a lot of AI astrologers being masked as real humans which are nothing but ChatGPT wrapper - these are the worst.

A lot of users using these platforms are young people who are at their most vulnerable stage.

Don't get me wrong, I believe AI in Astrology can be very helpful but only in certain cases.

To deal with this, I have decided to write down and collate a way for people to use AI for astrology and I need your help..

I want your raw thoughts on AI for Astrology. What do you think about it?

Have you used AI for astrology? Tell me:

  • Which tool or platform?
  • Good experience or bad?
  • Did you even know you were talking to AI?

Please comment your thoughts and experience.. I will collate the learnings and share.

reddit.com
u/Physical_Author_3887 — 1 month ago