Hot take: Requiring replies to Discussion Posts brings no value
It seems to be standard practice for instructors teachings online courses in Canvas to assign a discussion post and then require comments on one or two other student’s posts. I imagine these required replies were meant to recreate in-person class discussions and debate in an online environment, but the actual result is the opposite. Instead the easiest path to completion is empty praise and pandering agreement.
No true in-depth discussion is actually started, and no one bothers to return to read the replies their post received or respond to them. It is yet another failed attempt to mimic real life online with underwhelming results.
And yet, nearly all instructors employ this assignment structure. I have total respect for the ONE instructor who does follow this pattern. Few to none of the instructors engages or responds to any post or reply themselves, leading me to wonder if they’re readings them at all. And theirs is the opinion I‘m interested in most.