u/ProudSaint12

Been wanting to do an Easter for a while. If anyone is trying to squad up and knows how to do it, let me know 🙌. Any map is fine.

So, I really want the Supergirl HT, but I’m not sure how pre-orders work. I just checked, and the figure is supposed to come out sometime between July and December. Could it potentially come out this month? If so, should I wait until people have them in hand or just pre-order now? I also heard they come in waves after you pre-order.

I buy a lot of comics on Whatnot and have honestly never had an issue before. This was my first purchase from this particular seller. I paid about what a copy in the 8.5–9.0 range would typically sell for.

During the live stream, the seller didn’t give an exact grade, but he did say the comic only had “one spine tick” and briefly showed the front cover. When the comic arrived, I noticed multiple spine ticks along the back cover, as well as a noticeable crease across the Batman logo on the front that wasn’t visible during the stream. On top of that, there was a “5.0” sticker on the back of the comic when I received it.

I normally don’t like requesting refunds because I believe you should accept what you buy. However, in this case, I felt the comic’s condition was significantly different from how it was represented during the stream, especially considering the price I paid.
I contacted Whatnot support and requested a refund under “item not as described.”
Was I justified in doing that, or should I have just accepted it as part of buying comics through live streams?