Deciding between MYS and M3P AWD
I’ve been debating back and forth for a while on which Tesla to buy for my Guelph to Mississauga daily commute (approx. 120 kms) and have narrowed things down to the Model Y Standard vs. the Model 3 Premium AWD. Both cars land in the budget range I’ve set for myself.
The Y provides the obvious practicality advantages that come with the larger cabin and trunk space vs. the Model 3 AWD. The majority of the luxury amenities that are stripped out from the base Y (nicer seats, glass roof, faster acceleration, etc.) don’t bother me too much… but I would be sad not to have the killer audio system in the Premium 3.
The main areas that give me the most pause are the differences in battery chemistry and winter driving safety.
I like that the LFP battery in MYS can routinely charge to 100%, but my home and work parking are both outdoors, and my work doesn’t have charging stations available, so I worry about driving a cold-soaked battery home at the end of each day and how that will impact worst-case real-world range.
I’ve been a snow tire advocate for years (Michelin X-Ice has always been my choice), so I’m not as concerned with the snow/ice stopping ability of the MYS, but having never regularly driven a RWD car in winter, I worry about how the car will drive in the worst of the weather we see in southern Ontario… my daughter is 17 and neither her nor my wife are confident winter drivers… that really gives me the most pause.
I’m curious to hear what the experience for drivers who have had RWD Teslas over multiple years have been… I’m guessing a good analog to the MYS would be all the RWD Model 3’s with LFP batteries that are out there.