u/Rose_939

Like.. You can barely see his face or read his expressions in almost every key scene, while the supporting characters get all the reaction shots and close ups, even while delivering their dialogue. I noticed this many times..

Was the camera too shy to show his face and expressions, or what?

Or was the budget only enough for half a face? xD

AMA barely has a plot.. No hook, no head, no tail. There's only so much the director can do. It's like they just turned random X threads, social media comments, or self-help nonsense into a drama. Even the cast has said in official interviews that they don't strictly follow the script and often improvise, then turn around and claim that's why the show is supposedly so popular and loved.

The cast couldn't carry the show either. Weak writing and weak performances are a terrible combination, and no director can fix that, let alone FR, who's known for choppy editing even in IZN.

She also mentioned she had read about psychological concepts on Wikipedia. (Even though Wikipedia is a very basic source for understanding such topics, it still reflects a desire to be informed. These topics are vast branches of psychology with major academic references... However, at least she took the initiative to search and understand on her own)

Honestly, I really liked that because I appreciate this kind of mindset. I discussed it with her, and it was a very nice discussion.

On the other hand, in that same post, I was engaging with people whose approach was either just reacting with “haha” without even reading others’ comments or participating in the discussion, or simply dismissing everything by saying that no matter what is explained, it would still be “toxic” or a “red flag.”

Honestly, this type of mindsets make you feel sorry for them. almost even pity them.

On one side, you have a girl who admitted she initially didn’t understand the character because she wasn’t familiar with psychological aspects or physiology at all, but she searched, read, and tried to understand and analyze the character instead of limiting her mind. On the other side, you see this type of herd mentality. This girl even replied to their comments to help them understand, and that was really thoughtful.

This feels more like theatrical acting than natural acting. On top of that, most of the performances are extremely flat, especially Daniyal’s. He walks around with a K-pop idol hairstyle and vibe while supposedly playing a "sardar." How exactly am I supposed to buy into that? His acting feels very obvious and artificial. He seems lost and keeps trying to come across as serious, impactful, and emotionally compelling, but it just doesn’t work. As they say in Urdu, “wo sanjeeda rehny ki nakam koshish karta hai aur naak mein hi nun nun karta hai.”

​

His response is always silence. When his brother died, he was kept silent… and now again there are no emotional lines, no real acting.. just silence. His role offers no emotional depth or challenging dialogues that require real acting skills.. just a blank, expressionless face. His eyes feel completely empty, with no emotion at all.

​

In that video here, this scene where Sarbuland informed Rabia about Mudassir’s death felt incredibly flat. His delivery made it sound like he was telling her a bedtime story, almost detached. The slow-motion acting and lifeless dialogue delivery were unbelievable. He sounds nasal in almost every scene, as if he’s acting under gunpoint. I expected that moment to be powerful and emotional, but honestly, there was no genuine emotion on either of their faces. It was artificial acting.

​

The story itself is repetitive: the innocent, suffering heroine versus the other woman who is turned into the villain despite loving the hero since childhood. Farhat keeps relying on the same clichés instead of writing something fresh and creative.

​

Since YKS, Sajal’s performances have started to feel repetitive to me. She’s a fine actress, but her acting has become predictable. I won’t even talk about Sanam Baloch’s breakdown scenes in Dastaan, but if you want to see truly powerful emotional breakdowns after a husband’s death in recent scenes, look at Saba in Pamaal or Sabeena in MJ when her husband divorced her.

​

She used to be much better than this. I’m not saying this out of hate or any agenda—as I'm not even Pakistani or Indian lol. This is simply my honest opinion.

​

Also, Sajal’s heavy makeup, combined with the performance itself, made Ameer’s death scene feel far less impactful and realistic to me.

​

Her makeup in the hospital scene was unintentionally funny. I remember Neelam’s character in DMKD also wearing makeup during her father’s death scene, and people constantly criticized it back then, asking, “What kind of makeup is this?” because it looked unrealistic. But now I don’t see the same reaction or criticism.

​

The lighting is also poor, as if the whole production was shot under a single neon bulb, and the camera angles are not good either.

​

​

People nowadays chase hype and viral trends no matter what. Even some biased reviewers keep exaggerating their praise. Sajal and Daniyal’s chemistry still feels weak, yet people keep pushing them as a successful pairing even before their characters have properly interacted.

​

If another actress had delivered the exact same loud, theatrical performance, people wouldn’t be calling it one of the greatest scenes ever. But because it’s Sajal&hum TV, it gets praised as usual. The scene felt overly dramatic and followed her usual pattern in highly emotional breakdown sequences.

​

I genuinely get annoyed when people praise very ordinary scenes like Ameer’s death as if they were masterpieces. I don’t understand why parts of the media and some reviewers are treating this drama like a masterpiece. Trust me, Pak TV has produced far better dramas than this.

​

Please stop exaggerating 2.

Honestly, the first episode didn't offer anything that would make the audience feel excited or as if they were watching something special. The biggest issue it spends more time introducing characters than actually telling a story, so it ends without a strong event or clear conflict that would make viewers eager for the next episode.

​

The direction didn’t help much either. From the opening scene, the car shot was poorly executed. Many scenes looked visually unappealing and dull, and some shots gave off an older-drama vibe, even though this is supposed to be a modern production. The production value is really poor. Even the first and last scenes, which should have been impactful, were poorly executed and failed to leave any impression..

​

The editing and BGM were also major issues. At times, scenes that should have carried tension or emotional weight were linked with music that didn’t match the mood, which reduced their impact instead of enhancing it. The pacing was uneven as well.. some scenes dragged on for too long, while others felt rushed and didn’t leave any lasting impression.

​

Ahad seems to struggle with something as simple as portraying a casual, everyday character. It's like he is just acting rather than naturally living the role. His dialogue delivery and pronunciation are also hard to hear. His enunciation is horrible, and his voice is annoying. Like he just delivers his dialogues in a way that he's obviously like an average alcoholic guy, particularly in his scene with Saqib where he mocks Ruhi’s looks and makeup on TV—it came off as irritating.

​

Ironically, this made Maya seem better in comparison lol. The rest of the cast also felt inconsistent, especially the actress playing her sister.

​

The visual quality and color grading were also below average. The overall look felt dull and unpolished. The camera work was not engaging, and the shots appeared flat, lacking the cinematic appeal needed to hook viewers from the first episode. Nothing catchy at all in camera work.

​

Overall, my impression of the first episode.. It's below average. It’s not bad enough to dismiss the drama entirely, but it also doesn’t offer anything particularly impressive. We’ll have to wait and see if the upcoming episodes improve and make up for this dull/all over the place start.