u/Sad_Requirement_3559

As a kid those chain emails used to freak me out so badly, I’m guessing it was such a problem Nickelodeon had to step in LOL, i remember watching this episode and it took my fear away

I’m pretty sure they were going to mention him in a episode of season 1 or the episode was going to be about him but it was scraped, I would have loved to see or know more about Freddie’s dad

Imo I would say no, not only do none of the original writers or directors have to do with it (except if we count Josh peck) yes we have Nathan, Jerry, and miranda as directors but it just feels like a fanfict. Also Freddie was basically made a bum, and aside from me not even shipping creddie, the creddie buildup was absolutely terrible. No gibby or Sam (which btw before you comment about jennette I absolutely am aware of what happened and I don’t wish her to come back as Sam however they should 100 precent have recasted or not have made a reboot of one of the absolute main characters was missing.) I think Spencer was the only one I really liked. Anyways what do you guys think? Agree or disagree

Her whole family is so chaotic LOL

One of the funniest things about this whole Sam and Gibby situation in the episode is the fact that Sam has no romantic interest in him but can’t stand the fact that she got rejected by someone like him. She shows up to his house only because she refused to be rejected😂😭 kinda makes me realize how much she hated rejection which is probably why she wasn’t gonna go to the dance to begin with

Especially for edits I’m looking for season 5 and 6

Saw someone do this on tiktok with victorious so I’d thought I’d to it with icarly

Carly- (definitely a girl mom) would try to buy matching outfits for them a lot of the time, always makes sure she’s dressed up cute to go out, she tries to be there for her all the time and goes to all her school events making sure she never misses out on anything because of the absence of her own mom, would put her on Icarly and bring her to webshow events, she wouldn’t be too strict but makes sure she behaves well (kinda how she was with Sam) would make Spencer her daughters babysitter while she’s busy and he’d get her into art

Spencer: ABSOLUTELY a girl dad and aka ik in the revival he already has lots of kids as a sperm doner but nun that he really calls his own. I don’t really see him having his own kids or getting married but I’ll leave that to you guys what do you think?

Freddie: ( girl or boy dad either or (again aware about Millicent but she’s not his bio kid I think?) tries to teach his kids all types of tech skills, tries to get them into galaxy wars and even buys them galaxy war shirts to which they either love or hate, tries his hardest not to be as strict or over protective as his mother was but tends to fail Sometimes however he finally relaxes a bit, not the best at discipline and tends to give in when his kid has a tantrum or wants something even after saying “no” has like millions of pictures of his kids and is that “photo shoot” parent every birthday and holiday.

Gibby- (100 precent a boy dad) his kid would be as weird as him, he’d be a very chill parent, takes his kid with him everywhere, once his kid is older he’d get his kid a job at his restaurant, very good at saying “no” and discipline for some reason to the point where even Freddie would ask him for tips, asks if his kid can be on Icarly for every webshow, just like Carly he shows up at all his kids school events and stands up for his kid always

Sam- (for some odd reason she gives girl mom) I feel like with Sam she wouldn’t be one to want a kid but unexpectedly get pregnant. She’s very straight forward with her kid and is good at discipline never letting them over step boundaries and in a way tries to make sure they don’t end up like her with going to juvie, she would try hard to be a good mom because of how neglectful and horrible her own mom was to her, shed know a few things just from her babysitting days with cat but need Carly to help her out Sometimes, makes sure nobody messes with her kid and teaches them how to defend themself (but naturally her kid has her attitude and fighting strength) definitely a 1 and done type of mom, her kid and Carly’s become best friends

(FEEL FREE TO ADD MORE)

(if your a creddie shipper and have nothing good to say just don’t interact with the post n keep scrolling bruh😭)

Even though It’s sad that the writers had them break up in this episode it’s still my fav out of the 3 season 4 (Netflix) seddie eps because there was less chaos but as a seddie shipper even i know that the show wouldn’t be the same anymore having them stay together permanently. Especially since the writers weren’t wanting to do romance plots anyways and Icarly wasn’t even about that. Nathan has said it would have changed the dynamic of the trio and I agree. The breakup was clearly super forced because what carly said to Spencer and that babysitting girl had no correlation to sam and Freddie’s relationship/ development. But I love that they recognized it wasn’t about not loving each other since they literally said “I love you” to each other right after. It was most likely about all arguing (which I felt the writers could have done a better job on the seddie arc) I feel Carly should have not gaven them that type of advice even if she was trying to be helpful and just stay out of their relationship

Not sure if that was worded right lol! But I’ve seen a lot of unrealistic stuff on how others would make Sam have character development in the revival, i think there’s a way to make a character more mature without taking away from what made them,THEM. Remember that Sam was made to be the chaotic/ mean character and taking all of that away would completely ruin her character. I’m curious to know what you guys would have done to make her grow more as a person in the revival (if she was there) without completely changing her character

I know at the end he regretted breaking up with her but he def made the right decision as much as he liked her and while watching I felt very proud of him for doing so. I wish creddie shippers understood that in the og icarly Carly did not like Freddie. And even in the revival she tells him she kissed him for closure in the last episode. There was no development through the series that showed she liked him, even the dance at the groovie smoothie wouldn’t have happened if Carly got a good date. This episode made me feel really bad for Freddie but in Carly’s defense she could have thought she owed him it since he saved her life so no hate to her. Ik you guys will probably downvote me to hell for this but the relationship in the revival was super forced and him waiting 30 years for her is not cute or “awe he’s a yearner” and even as a seddie shipper It would have been better if he ended up with someone else in the revival instead of Carly.