If you could keep only one item in your collection, what would it be and why?

For me it would have to be my Naruto volume 1 English first print. Before they started popping up on eBay this year, I spent almost all of 2025 trying to find a copy. I went through dozens, if not hundreds, of listings looking for one until I accidentally stumbled on one of the copies I have now. That feeling of finding something I’d been hunting for so long was amazing and definitely restarted my love for collecting manga!

reddit.com
u/ScarcityMode — 10 days ago

First Appearance of Demon Slayer Recent Sale

This is a HOT take….but with the next Demon Slayer movie coming in 2027 (and a certain fight about to be adapted iykyk….) I could definitely see this being a steal.

Plus this first appearance came out a decade ago, so 9.8’s aren’t exactly super common either.

What do you think?

u/ScarcityMode — 22 days ago

One Piece canon first appearance has just sold for over $800,000

Do you think it’ll reach $1,000,000? If so, why? If not, why not?

u/ScarcityMode — 1 month ago

Introducing the r/MangaRarity Weekly Marketplace!

Every Friday, a new Marketplace thread will be posted where members can:

Sell manga from their collections
Post manga they're looking to buy
Trade with other collectors
Find rare Zasshi, OOP, first-print, vintage, and unusual editions

The goal is to give collectors a dedicated place to buy, sell, and trade while keeping the main r/MangaRarity feed focused on manga rarity, collecting, identification, discussion, and discovery.

Going forward, individual sales and advertisements should be posted in the Weekly Marketplace rather than as standalone posts.

The first Weekly Manga Marketplace is live now and pinned at the top of the subreddit.

As the Marketplace develops, definitely open to feedback from the community about what you'd like to see from it.

Happy collecting!

reddit.com
u/ScarcityMode — 2 months ago

Creating weekly buy/sell thread

Starting this Friday, there will be a weekly thread for buying and selling in this subreddit. This is to prevent advertising products outside of the weekly thread. Starting tomorrow, the only buying and selling posts allowed will have to be on that weekly thread. More details will be on the first thread tomorrow!

reddit.com
u/ScarcityMode — 2 months ago

Perspective on English on Kagurabachi Market

Disclosure: I own a few raw English first prints of Kagurabachi volume 1 so I have an interest in the prices of this volume.

Ever since the anime was announced for Kagurabachi there’s been a sharp increase in the prices for its Zasshi first appearance and Japanese volume 1 first printing on the secondary market.

To my surprise though, this has slowly made its way to the English first print market as well. Recently there’s been a few sales of BGS English volume 1 first prints in English and now, a raw English first print just sold as well.

With the caveat of the sale still needing to be finalized, there was only 1 bid, and we don’t know if this was a one off, I’m really surprised that it sold for this amount.

From what I’ve seen in the English first print market, the only volumes that sell around this price or higher (in the hundreds of $) are the OP, Dragon ball, Dragon ball Z, Bleach, and Naruto vol 1 first prints. In general though, that may be starting to change as more Berserk, Hunter X Hunter, and older English first prints come to the market.

However, my main point is that this sale to my knowledge was the first modern (post 2020) English first print to sale for this amount.

I think it’s definitely fueled by the anime hype but I’m interested to see if (1) This continues to happen with English first print Kagurabachi volumes and (2) Whether this will happen to other very modern properties that gain popularity going forward.

What do you think?

u/ScarcityMode — 2 months ago

What rare manga category do you collect the most and why?

For me it’s English first prints, with Zasshi first appearances close behind. I enjoy the hunt to find English first prints and Zasshi first appearances usually have great art and are such cool pieces of history.

reddit.com
u/ScarcityMode — 3 months ago

Big Half-Price Books 1st print haul!!

Believe it or not, 6/8 of the these were from one location lol. I think the coolest find is the Ranma 1/2 volume, since it’s from before Viz turned to the Japanese format of reading manga (right to left).

But the one I’m most happy with is The Promised Neverland. I read it when it first came out but my original volume 1 copy was somehow a second print lol.

u/ScarcityMode — 3 months ago

Hot Take: English convention exclusives are severely underrated and will reach the same tier as the English /5000 holofoils

I’m referring to the 2015 NYCC Naruto Volume 72 Exclusive, the 2018 My Hero Academia SDCC exclusive, and the 2019 One Punch Man SDCC exclusive.

These were primarily only handed out at the events aside from a few select bookstore locations so there aren’t that many out there. Plus they’re pretty hard to find on third party platforms.

u/ScarcityMode — 4 months ago

Half Price Books Spy x Family First Print Find!

A week ago I went to a few Half-Price books in my area (my first time going to Half-Price books stores) looking for manga. At most of the locations there wasn’t much, but I did see a second English print of Food wars and Shaman King that weren’t too bad.

But then I stumbled upon this Spy X Family volume. Immediately I thought that there was no way this was a first print since the first printing came out in 2020 and it looked like it was in great condition. When I saw I was wrong I instantly bought it lol (for $6).

Have you ever found any cool manga at a discount store?

u/ScarcityMode — 4 months ago
▲ 600 r/MangaRarity+1 crossposts

According to multiple leaks, BLEACH by Tite Kubo will be returning to Weekly Shonen Jump with a 'Hell Arc' serialization.

SAKAMOTO DAYS by Yuto Suzuki will be ending in the upcoming weeks, freeing a slot in the magazine for this new BLEACH series.

u/ScarcityMode — 4 months ago

Slight repost but in honor of the Japanese WC last minute draw yesterday…Blue Lock!!

I bought the first print when it came out in 2022.

The Barnes and Noble exclusive is a 2nd print fun fact. I’ve never been able to find the first print.

The BAM exclusive was the hardest one to find. As far as I know they only had one printing of it and not a lot have been sold on the secondary market.

u/ScarcityMode — 4 months ago

First English Appearance of One Piece in Shonen Jump #0 Question

If anyone in here has a raw copy of Shonen Jump 0, can you confirm what One Piece characters appear? From research, I think a few pages of Romance Dawn 2 are shown, and in those pages I think it’s just Luffy. Would love to confirm!

u/ScarcityMode — 4 months ago
▲ 21 r/MangaRarity+1 crossposts

Which would you rather have?

Imagine you had the chance to be gifted a BGS 8.0 of:

(1) WSJ 1968 #1 (First issue of Weekly Shonen Jump)
(2) WSJ 1984 #52 (First appearance of Dragon Ball)
(3) WSJ 1997 #34 (First canon appearance of One Piece)

You’d get one of these for free. Which would you decide to get?👀

u/ScarcityMode — 4 months ago